• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Demo videos: must they suck?

scottfeldstein

Roots and fifths and a little extra.
Jun 20, 2011
6,544
4,412
57
San Marcos, California
endlessblue.bandcamp.com
If you're like me you do a lot of research before buying a pedal. If you're also like me and you don't live in the middle of a major metropolitan area filled with well stocked music stores you do a lot of that research online. With headphones. On youtube. Couldn't live without those demo videos put up by amateurs and publishers alike. But after having spent countless hours with these videos I have to ask: do they have to suck so much?

The problems are many and varied. Off the top of my head, and in no particular order:

1. The bass is being played by a guitar player... who plays bass like a guitar player.

2. The bass audio is just the ambient sound of the guy's amp going through the same mic he's talking to you with. You can even hear the unamplified string noise over the amp.

3. The bass is being played in a strange style for the entire demo: like all in chords above the 12th fret. Why?

4. The player has chosen to set one key knob on the effect in a strange position and then leaves it there for the entire demo while he laboriously demos the range of every other flipping knob on the thing. Can having the Blend knob set for 75% clean signal help anyone better understand this miracle effect? It cannot.

5. The video is so slickly produced and heavily scripted that it's narrator ends up saying things that don't mean anything except to their marketing department. "Giving you PURE BASS TONE!" Um, it's a bypass switch. It's not "giving" me anything.

I could go on. I'm sure you could, too. (And perhaps you will in the comments.) But now that my rant is through I should pause for a genuine thank you to everyone who puts up these videos. Some of them are great, many of them are ..not. But having them there is a lot better than not having them.
 
They should add a category to the Oscar

"And the Oscar for the best Gear demo Video goes to..... "

I also hate these videos as much as I appreciate them being there, but I understand now, after doing a few vids just for fun , that most of these vids are are done by bored musicians like me... Who really want to share their sound and when they push REC they no longer know what to play

Heheheheheheheheh


But I just can't understand the demos with a camera mic and horrible sound like that
 
When you get it home it's going to sound different than the video anyway. Everything else has a pretty big effect on the performance of any given pedal. Your Bass, Its strings, your amp, your cabinet, your attack etc....
 
  • Like
Reactions: MightyMiloQuinn
I started recording videos as a bored musician because I couldn't find any. I don't do many today, because that niche is mostly filled. I'm glad of the resource, and I understand that its not easy to do a 'good' video, and it's impossible to do a video that will please everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirMjac28 and jwr