I put my Super PJ with P solo’d up against an American Fender P. Same amp, both me and my buddy taking turns playing each bass back to back. Pick, finger style, slap, both with nickel rounds.
Passive on the Dingwall, passive Fender P. Tone up, tone down, whatever the Fender P did the Dingwall could match. I’m confident I can nail a P sound.
We had the other band members look away and try to guess which was which. They got bored. Started drinking. Not the most cooperative bunch.
Put the Dingwall Super into the other gears, parallel and series with both pickups, or crank the solo bridge pup, or add in the Glockenlang pre, and there is a world of range the Fender P wasn’t going to do.
No comparison on the feel. Not even close.
I have a 63 AVRI P that I installed EMG Geezer’s in. Killer tone. Pretty big difference between the S P/J. However, and like I said, the P pup solo’d is awesome.
