Hi all,
Looking at a Lee Sklar 5 string model with 3 pickups.
Can anyone explain the difference between that and a Z3? Seems to be exactly the same with the addition of a hipshot extender on the B string and potentially different pickup selector options? If so, how are the options different from the Z3 and is there anything else which is different?
Cheers!
I banged away on my Dingwall spec sheet deciding between a Z and a Sklar for a week. I also consulted with Dingwall’s premier dealer on the matter.
From a player’s point of view, a Sklar is basically a Z with smaller frets, a hipshot, and the Northern ash/alder dual-density body. The electronics suite is a bit different on a Sklar than on a what is stock on a Z - the Sklar has a 250 Hz active midrange and no series/parallel switches. On the decorative side, you get Sheldon Dingwall’s signature on the headstock of a Z and Sklar’s signature on the headstock of his model.
It’s important to note that the Z model is much more customizable than the Sklar. The Sklar is the Sklar and that’s it. The thing with Dingwall is that you can’t pick and choose certain distinctives of a Sklar model to go on a similar Z - you can’t get Sklar-specific mandolin frets on any other model and you can’t get the Sklar-specific preamp on a Z. To clarify, Sklar chose a 250 Hz midrange on the Glockenklang preamp on his bass, and the stock Z has a 550 Hz midrange on the same Glockenklang preamp - same pre, different frequency points. Sklar runs his boosts on the hotter side when he plays the Dingwall and he wanted the 250 Hz. You can get instructions from a few obvious sources on how to switch the mid frequency on the Glockenklang yourself. They just won’t do it at the factory. If I’m correct, you also can’t get premium fingerboard inlays on a Sklar - it’s dots and the “D” on the 12th fret. They’re considerably behind in production and apparently won’t entertain these requests and I recall a possible desire to keep a Sklar a Sklar and not get it watered down with all sorts of deviations from the original design. No biggie, as far as I’m concerned.
My upcoming build is a Z - basically a Sklar with no Hipshot, no Sklar signature, regular non-mando frets, and the 550 mid on the pre. It could be mistaken for a Sklar from 10 feet away, if Sklar’s signature wasn’t a consideration. All I really wanted was a Sklar with regular frets but that wasn’t possible. Since Dingwall wouldn’t build a Sklar like I wanted, I ordered a Z to get it.
I’ve played a Z and a Sklar one right after the other and they’re more similar than different - whichever one is best for you is how well you get along with what’s on the build sheet.