After some time with my new Payson bridge, I’d like to give my assessment. The main reason is because if I knew these things before buying I may have made a different choice, and you may as well, or maybe not. Who knows! All in the interest of getting information out there to those who may benefit.
TLDR, I’m mostly happy with it, but it’s not perfect, and I will be replacing it with the DW Minimalist Bridge as soon as it’s available.
It started with me never liking smoked chrome hardware. I always associate it with cheap Ibanez’s from 20 years ago. It needed replacing if for nothing else than aesthetic purposes. With options for drop-in replacements being limited for DW NG/Combustion models, I went with the best looking I could find.
The Payson is definitely an aesthetic upgrade, IMO! But I have some gripes.
When I read “Guaranteed Drop in Fit” with no other listed caveats, I expect a true drop-in replacement with full advertised functionality. This is not the case. It’s only drop-in because the screw holes line up, if I may be honest.
1. The bridge sits at a slight angle to the bass side. This causes a horizontal break angle at the saddles. The result is that the bridge cannot support string width adjustments because the horizontal tension will always force the string to the high side.
Documentation on the website about specifics is sparse, so going on memory of what I’ve read here is that the bridge is adjustable from 18-19mm (I could be wrong). DW 5/6ers are 18mm. With the Payson bridge native limitations I’m guessing this means the string spacing is now 18.5mm, with the bass side B string being perfect and each higher string slightly more and more “off”, or pushed slightly to the high side.
This could be worked around with some type of shims, I suppose, which could be slipped between the high-side saddle and inside of the bridge to achieve OEM specs of 18mm, but to get the appropriately sized shims, we’ll, I don’t exactly know where to start looking. And I don’t care to at this point.
2. As opposed to the OEM single-string saddles with 2 screws, the Payson has 1 row of screw holes. What happens here is that the ground wire that runs the length of the bridge acts as a fulcrum so that the bridge doesn’t have full contact with the bass body. I’m not entirely sure how this affects tone yet but I’m sure it does to some extent. What I do know is that it affects string action quite a bit.
With the ground wire in normal position, the best action I could achieve at the G/C strings was 5/64”. I strongly prefer 3/64” for low action. My end result after 3 install attempts and full setups (over the course of 8-10 hours) got me just above 4/64” (with a straight af board). Workable, but not super optimal.
With the OEM double-screw type bridges, they basically clamp down over the wire creating more contact to get around this issue.
My “drop-in” workaround for this was moving the ground wire behind the screws. This helped tip the bridge forward to achieve the better action I mentioned. However, the bridge still doesn’t sit flush with the body. There is still a paper-thin gap throughout. And this is after I also tried to flatten out the wire quite a bit and press it into the poly finish with very significant torque on the bridge screws.
If you’re looking for a permanent install and don’t mind some work done on your bass, I would personally get a luthier to 1. remount the bridge so the strings are straight in the saddles allowing normal string width adjustment, and 2. cutting the ground wire as close as possible to the hole it comes out of since only that corner of the bridge next to the ground wire hole is bare of paint and can work as the ground, and potentially dremelling out a little notch there so the bridge can sit flush while still maintaining contact.
Pics of horizontal break angle
View attachment 5319645 View attachment 5319646
Pic of ground wire in normal placement
View attachment 5319649
At the end of the day, I could see most people being super happy with the bridge! I, however, am a ridiculous perfectionist. I will “live with” (fairly happily) this great option until the DW Minimalist bridge becomes available as Sheldon has mentioned should be coming in the near future.
Hope this helps!