I'm curious about this as I own an AB1 w/ a P-tone and 2 FDVs and haven't had issues, I think the P-tone was not factory installed,
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Dingwall Owners Club
- Thread starter FroggyOne2
- Start date
Hi Guys!I don’t, sorry. Ryan over at [email protected] usually replies pretty fast, though
All of our necks use the same polyurethane satin finish. They can all be cleaned with regular guitar polish. Hope this helps
Luminlay side dots are an easy DIY. Especially with bolt on necks, where you can remove the neck to do the work.
Y'all crazy for thinking that removing strings, a neck, drilling, and gluing is easier than turning a screw driver to remove and reinstall like, a dozen small screws 
Please post the answer. I have Z3 with a P-tone installed by Bassdirect (UK) and 2 FDVs and I don't notice anything odd either except for the annoying and well known differences in volume between some configurations (loudest is bridge-middle, most quiet is bridge solo).
I have done this. The order was different, and the pairs were specifically all parallel, none were in series. It was fine. I find bridge solo to be useless for what I do. I also didn't like NM in parallel at all. Other than that I found uses for the other settings. The MB parallel setting is oddly more usable than MB series in many settings, but at the same time is a way less exciting sound, so that one is a take it or leave it, even though it was formerly my most used setting.
I removed that switch and replaced it with the usual 6-way that's described as "the best of the 3X and D-Roc switches in a single package" offered by Mo. I did re-order the settings, but they're all the same otherwise.
I have 3x P-tones with switches from the factory. Not sure why you can't use switches with P-Tones. Mine seem to flip up and down and the bass doesn't fall apart. That said, I'd probably switch them to FDVs if I could buy the pickups somewhere.
I'm not sure exactly why, but... I think it's because the FDV is an alnico pickup and the rest are neodynium, so they think it hurts the sound.
I'll ask him again.
At the time I ordered my specs, I was really into P TONE and SF2, so I wasn't really interested in FDVs...
I think I can answer that.
It's not that you can't use them.
But for the p tone you have to put them in series to get the normal p tone, you won't get that sound if you put them in parallel.
I think that's what he meant.
Of course, it's not impossible to put a switch on them.
I don't know what order Mo would place them in, I have no real preference. My SJ5XXX also has the switches. I have a SFII, Ptone, and FDV pickups. I switched my stock settings so that I have middle solo, which is my favorite setting, followed by neck solo. I will put the SFII in the bridge, having not been happy with either the FD3 or FDV there (stock solo setting). I have also not been blown away by the mb. The nm was fine for my Classic Country band, but not so much for my Biker Rock Band.
Ptones are wired in series, aren't they? Did you notice any change in tone using the toggles? I would expect at least a volume change.
I actually moved away from my SJ5XXX to Thunderbirds for several years. Then I discovered SushiBox pedals and thought I'd give the Dingwall another go, and that middle solo tone through SushiBox is putting it back in the rotation. Totally awe inspiring
I don't know what order Mo would place them in, I have no real preference. My SJ5XXX also has the switches. I have a SFII, Ptone, and FDV pickups. I switched my stock settings so that I have middle solo, which is my favorite setting, followed by neck solo. I will put the SFII in the bridge, having not been happy with either the FD3 or FDV there (stock solo setting). I have also not been blown away by the mb. The nm was fine for my Classic Country band, but not so much for my Biker Rock Band.
Ptones are wired in series, aren't they? Did you notice any change in tone using the toggles? I would expect at least a volume change.
I actually moved away from my SJ5XXX to Thunderbirds for several years. Then I discovered SushiBox pedals and thought I'd give the Dingwall another go, and that middle solo tone through SushiBox is putting it back in the rotation. Totally awe inspiring
You can't go wrong soloing the middle pickup.
If I could have, I would have specified that only a middle pickup be installed in my four-string AB-I (it could have been my signature bass 
). The bridge and neck pickups might as well not be there, because I never use them. Come to think of it, it would also be cool if the Droc were available with only the middle pickup. It would be like the Series II (my favorite!) Thunderbird. 
I received the following reply
You cannot mix FDV with other pickups unless the bass only has 2 pickups that are not next to each other. The FDV pickups have Alnico magnets. The other types all have neodymium magnets which are very, very strong. The neodymium magnets will erase the alnico magnets and kill the pickups if they are right next to each other for a few months.
I'm confused because I didn't see any problems here.
Are your p-tone pickups alnico magnets?
If so, I don't think you'll have any problems, but I know that the p-tone Dingwall is currently using is neodymium.
I should curse thee, sir. You're making me reconsider my build again. SO hot.I'm a passive guy, only using the glock occasionaly for very specific tones/songs but the Neve is super versatile and always "musical". The passive cut over active mode is a great and useful new feature. Get the Neve. Also... it's silly but I do not like the placement of the 3 knobs on the SJ5 - I think it looks a bit weird - much better with the 5 knobs.
My SJ5 is Nothern Ash and Alder (roasted ash neck) - I confirm it is heavy (that's the one John is referring to) but I knew that was coming and did not mind much. With this heavy body, no neck dive... but I somehow doubt you would have a problem with lighter body woods - the SJ is bottom heavy
Personally I llove the roasted ash feel (slight preference for Wenge, but to me it provides a much smoother feel than maple).
I have parallel switches and 6 way switches on my 3 dingwalls, but if I'm honest, 95% of the time it's basically all set to series except when using Bridge+Middle together in Series (in which case I typically set one of the pickup - usually the mid - to parallel). Then really occasionally (again very specific tones/songs) I'd use a solo pickup in parallel. I could easily live with a push pull on the middle pickup instead of three switches. Also with my SJ5 (Ptone + SFiis) the neck switch is actually useless (P-tone has to stay in series).
And pic for the road:
View attachment 7071058
What's the top on this - black with white hard stop?
Pardon my ignorance but I googled SJ5XXX and couldn't find any references in the internet but your posts. What model is that?I don't know what order Mo would place them in, I have no real preference. My SJ5XXX also has the switches. I have a SFII, Ptone, and FDV pickups. I switched my stock settings so that I have middle solo, which is my favorite setting, followed by neck solo. I will put the SFII in the bridge, having not been happy with either the FD3 or FDV there (stock solo setting). I have also not been blown away by the mb. The nm was fine for my Classic Country band, but not so much for my Biker Rock Band.
Ptones are wired in series, aren't they? Did you notice any change in tone using the toggles? I would expect at least a volume change.
I actually moved away from my SJ5XXX to Thunderbirds for several years. Then I discovered SushiBox pedals and thought I'd give the Dingwall another go, and that middle solo tone through SushiBox is putting it back in the rotation. Totally awe inspiring
I have a SJ5xx with a P-tone in the neck and an FDV in the bridge.
No issues.
For the classic rock band I'm in...sounds great!
(97.3% of the time I use the Bridge-Neck-in-series mode - #3 position)
As mentioned in the text, there's nothing to worry about with a traditional 2-pickup split.I have a SJ5xx with a P-tone in the neck and an FDV in the bridge.
No issues.
For the classic rock band I'm in...sounds great!
(97.3% of the time I use the Bridge-Neck-in-series mode - #3 position)
View attachment 7072977
By the way, I'm thinking of changing the neck pickup on my Superj4xx from fdv to p-tone, are you happy with the current pickup?
