TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I think solid black without the white lamination would look better.This is my current No. 2 bass (Fender American Performer P). Although the bass looks good with the black pickguard, I keep thinking about replacing it with a tort pickguard. The problem is because the regular P pickguard doesn't fit with this bass, I'd have to order a tort pickguard made for this model from WD. The total would be about $130 (yikes!). What do you think?
View attachment 7162890
View attachment 7162891
What do I think? I think that there isn't a bass in this arm of the Milky Way Galaxy, that needs a tort pickguard. Personally? There are 3 P-Bass shaped basses in my herd - all 3TB finished, - and none of them have a tort pickguard. My '24 Custom Shop G&L Kiloton lined fretless bass used to have one; now, it has the same Cream/Black/Cream 'guard that my '78 Fender P-Bass, and my '18 Warmoth Mini-Precision Bass have. The Fender originally had a solid Black one, but it was badly cracked when I bought it (in 1988). I thought it looked a little... gloomy... so I replaced it. IMO, Cream/Black/Cream just looks.... classy... with a 3TB finish. But, I'm sure all the Tort-ites will be urging you to join them; and, it is your bass, after all. So, if you want to go the tort route you can 1) settle for a "regular" one - that will almost certainly look like pizza-with-extra-sauce pewk; or 2) spend big $$'s for a pickguard that actually looks like tortoiseshell. Which I guarantee you will cost a lot more than $130....This is my current No. 2 bass (Fender American Performer P). Although the bass looks good with the black pickguard, I keep thinking about replacing it with a tort pickguard. The problem is because the regular P pickguard doesn't fit with this bass, I'd have to order a tort pickguard made for this model from WD. The total would be about $130 (yikes!). What do you think?
View attachment 7162890
View attachment 7162891

Yes. Black on sunburst looks a bit ordinary to me.This is my current No. 2 bass (Fender American Performer P). Although the bass looks good with the black pickguard, I keep thinking about replacing it with a tort pickguard. The problem is because the regular P pickguard doesn't fit with this bass, I'd have to order a tort pickguard made for this model from WD. The total would be about $130 (yikes!). What do you think?
View attachment 7162890
View attachment 7162891