TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Correct thanks for posting ! In the first 10 years of The Who pick or fingers was about 50/50.Actually EntWISTLE used both his fingers and a pick throughout his career. There's all kinds of footage of him using a pick, even later on. He used whatever fit the song best.
In my experience, the bassists who make silly statements about 'real' bass players not using picks, usually have no game with a pick, or are scared to try and work on their pick playing as it may prove challenging. I think it can only make you a better bassist, being able to play with your fingers and I pick.
I regularly use a pick on sessions with my P bass strung with flats, and always get complimented on my tone, and how the note sits against the kick drum. Plus its just kinda fun to be able switch between pick/fingers live to change it up and explore ways to control both. And yeah, you dont have to look very far to garner a pretty big list of famous/pro players who use plectrums as part of their tone![]()
Haven't seen a thread on this yet. I have often heard that real bass players use their fingers and NEVER use a pick (shudder) but I have learned that a good number of famous bassists actually use picks and that a pick is a part of their signature sound.
I started out using a pick (because I am a guitar player, after all) but weaned myself off because I wanted to become a "Real" bass player!
Here are some iconic bass players who use a plectrum (Pick).:
Chris Squire - Yes (Not just that "Rick" giving that signature sound)
Mel Schacher - GFR
John Lodge - Moody Blues
Tommy Shannon - SRV and Double Trouble
Roger Waters - Pink Floyd
Paul McCartney - The Beatles
I do not know about anyone else here but I will not be telling these guys they are not bass players because they use a pick!