Another band that I love and has not been mentioned is The Hives.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
What is real rock then? It doesn't encompass everything, but it always has contained a lot. Hence the terms southern rock, blues rock, pop rock, punk rock, hard rock, etc. Those aren't exactly new designations. Even if you can name what exactly real rock is, I doubt you could get any kind of consensus to agree.
From what I see here "Rock" means everything that isn't Jazz or Classical. Which mean it incompass folk, country, punk, grunge, pop, rap, hiphop, new age, metal and all the subgenres, disco, motown, dance, electronic...etc it becomes stupid
From this thread everything in those two clip are under the "rock" umbrella ...
From what I see here "Rock" means everything that isn't Jazz or Classical. Which mean it incompass folk, country, punk, grunge, pop, rap, hiphop, new age, metal and all the subgenres, disco, motown, dance, electronic...etc it becomes stupid
From this thread everything in those two clip are under the "rock" umbrella ...
You still haven't explained what "real rock" is.
You still haven't said what you define rock as. Elvis? The Stones? Korn? Give a band name or something. Like I said before, I'm 43. 1974. Ever since that day rock I've known rock as a huge umbrella. I don't know when that changed. Or why it's such a big deal if it encompasses large amounts of music. Personally I think all these subgenres are a little stupid. Why quibble over whether The Cranberries are rock, or whether they are Euro-grunge post rock folk? Does this really matter?
Queen, Led Zep, ACDC, Elvis etc
Queen, Led Zep, ACDC, Elvis etc
So rock's defining trait is...? Because those band have little in common. The grunge bands have more in common with LZ then LZ has with Elvis. Queen was all over the place.
Great, so let's mention Opeth, and lump them in with those great bands he mentioned. Respect to Black Sabbath and Metallica....to give the metal guys their due. Then, just let's leave it there. Take your power chords....just take any note you like, and add a fifth interval.....and piss off !!
Great, so let's mention Opeth, and lump them in with those great bands he mentioned. Respect to Black Sabbath and Metallica....to give the metal guys their due. Then, just let's leave it there. Take your power chords....just take any note you like, and add a fifth interval.....and piss off !!

I like Collective Soul too. They had a good run of songs starting in the early 1990s. Here are a few.
Yah, I'm a big Collective Soul fan. And the Dosage Album is probably my favorite. I'll add this tune that for reasons unexplained to me, always makes me feel good..
and of course this...
and finally this...
Fishheadjoe