• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Favorite stand up comedian

George Carlin, Jerry Seinfeld, Rich Little, Frank Gorshin, Johnny Carson, Don Rickles, of whom I have a story. From 1971 to 1973, when I was 21-23, I was a production assistant on the Johnny Mann Singers TV show, Standup and Cheer, and also the road manager for live gigs. We were booked for a week to open for Don Rickles in Las Vegas, two shows a night. As soon as we finished each show, I would stand in the wings and watch Don at work. It was fascinating to see how well prepared he was for any audience member with stuff that he had ready to go at a moments notice. It was the same material show to show, just waiting for the appropriate person to spring it on.

He was also such a nice guy off stage. The first time I was in the wings, with him very near ready to go on, he asked me my name, what I did there, and complimented me on being so young for such a responsible job, gave me a real confidence boost. From then on, as he walked past me to go on stage, he'd gesture like he's hitting me in the crotch, and of course I flinched every time. When he walked off, he shook my hand as he passed.

Later when I was a propman in the movie studios, I worked on two Bill Crystal Movies (Mr. Saturday Night and Forget Paris), Billy was just naturally funny, with almost every word out of his mouth a great joke. Just the opposite was Steve Martin (All of Me and L.A. Story). Off camera he was the most unassuming person as can be. He would sit quietly in his chair, rarely in his trailer, just watching what was going on, sometime practicing little card tricks, just for himself, not anyone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BadJazz and bass12
Wow, I was just about to say, doesn’t anyone in this music-focused group like Bill Bailey? You beat me to it. Hilarious.


I first saw Bill Bailey in the show Black Books, which starred another comedian I enjoy - Dylan Moran.

Patton Oswalt is a perennial favorite. Also enjoy Kyle Kinane, Chris Gethard, Brian Posehn, and pretty much everyone already named in this thread.

Also I'll throw out a mention of a good friend/bandmate from college who's now a standup - Adam Newman. Very funny guy. Observe -
 
Michelle Wolf and Sarah Silverman's last few Netflix specials have been great. They're definitely 2 of my faves.

Also saw Tim Meadows do standup last year and he was really funny. He makes any movie/show that he's in better.
 
I’ve been really into Sam Morril for a while now. Dry with fantastic timing. I’ve been following him since he was a guest comedian on Conan O’Brien. His friend Mark Normand is very different in style but I love his awkward nonchalant punchlines.

Eddie Murphy’s “Delirious” is absolutely brilliant and Russell Peter’s very first special is excellent.

Louis CK was monumental to me when I first discovered his “Chewed Up”. I’m actually gonna see him live in Tokyo next March. My first pro level comedy show!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Low Down Brown
First Album I bought with my own money

1763697926538.png


Carlin, Pryor, and Hicks are probably the most important overall
My go-to's lately are the cerebral one liners of Mitch Hedberg and Dimitri Martin (saw Steven Wright live back in the 80s)

But the 2 routines that have struck me the most are
Doug Stanhope's 2013 bit in Beer Hall Pustch about assisting his Mother's suicide
and Dave Chappelle's 8:23 about the murder of George Floyd
Both deal with weighty subjects using humor and pathos.
 
For a while it was Steven Wright but eventually his jokes started sounding repetitive and as he got older he seemed to lose his edge.

I actually met Steven Wright in NYC at a friend's wedding in the mid 90's. He was a childhood friend of the woman my friend was getting married to. I love his work and am surprised he hasn't been more successful than he has.
 
I’m old school, so it’s Rodney Dangerfield, Jonathon Winters, Tim Conway, Bob Newhart…..
Many years ago I went to a concert and the opening act was a no show. Robert Klein was in town so they got him up there. He was pretty funny.
In the 21st century? Not gonna lie. Larry the Cable Guy makes me laugh. Also Steven Wright, Mitch Hedburg.
 
  • Like
Reactions: darev
For whatever reason, stand-up has never been a genre I really paid too much attention to. I couldn't do a top-ten because I don't follow enough comedians to be able to pick ten. And a fair amount of when I do catch some, it's either trying to get a cheap laugh with a vulgarity, or being preachy under the pretext of comedy. Never found either of those funny. Comedy is a craft where you really have to set it up and then pop a surprise or reversal to create the comedic tension.

The comedian that I absorbed and enjoyed most growing up was Bill Cosby. But of course, it's complicated to say that, now that we know everything he was up to. They often say that great humor comes from somewhere dark, and we now know that as wholesome as his act was, his psyche was a very dark place. But it WAS comic genius. I sometimes wonder if he's going to go down in history as a brilliant comedian, with a footnote that he was up to terrible things in secret, or if he'll be remembered as a high profile fall from grace, with the footnote being that he had been a popular comedian once.

My others would be relatively obscure. One is another one from my childhood, where I used to steal my dad's records and listen to them. Bert and I was the work of a couple of guys named Malcolm Dodge and Bob Bryan. It was extremely dry, quintessentially Yankee humor, and a lot of folks don't get it, but it's very much ingrained in my psyche.


Another is a regional comedian who was big in our circle when I was in grad school in Indiana. He's a singing comedian named Heywood Banks, also a very wholesome act (and I hope without Cosby's skeletons in his closet).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5StringBlues