Reversing the tones as you suggested will sound the same. Keep listening closely and you might see that... That has been my experience and also the experience of many with the stacked knob setup (as configured in the reissue jazz). Read some posts here about it...
I thought the same as you until i *really* listened (and recorded a couple quick clips) and there is no difference. If you really want there to be a difference, you can make yourself think it's there. Same thing happened to me. But do a little research into how the wiring is setup, and i think all of this will make sense
Trying not to sound condescending, since i HATE it when people do that to me on TB...
The tones ALWAYS bleed w/o resistors when they are wired in such a way as the stacked knob setup is. The way to think of it simply is that whatever volume you're favoring, THAT's the tone control that will have the most effect (most all for that matter). With both volumes maxed, you'll find (with some more experimentation i think) that the resulting effect is the same -- no matter which tone you roll off completely.
And i'm not trying to do a "vs" thread, just more encouraging everyone to try and wire it up with the resistors, and then 1) you'll be in pre-62 jazz bass land ala Fender's original wiring and 2) you'll see the real benefit of having two tone controls over VVT (as far as versatility goes). It'll be darker tho...
I thought the same as you until i *really* listened (and recorded a couple quick clips) and there is no difference. If you really want there to be a difference, you can make yourself think it's there. Same thing happened to me. But do a little research into how the wiring is setup, and i think all of this will make sense
The tones ALWAYS bleed w/o resistors when they are wired in such a way as the stacked knob setup is. The way to think of it simply is that whatever volume you're favoring, THAT's the tone control that will have the most effect (most all for that matter). With both volumes maxed, you'll find (with some more experimentation i think) that the resulting effect is the same -- no matter which tone you roll off completely.
And i'm not trying to do a "vs" thread, just more encouraging everyone to try and wire it up with the resistors, and then 1) you'll be in pre-62 jazz bass land ala Fender's original wiring and 2) you'll see the real benefit of having two tone controls over VVT (as far as versatility goes). It'll be darker tho...
Regardless of the tone interaction with the stack knobs minus the resistors, there are still more options than with the VVT. How can there not be. A selection I use often when playing with a pick is both volumes full up, bridge tone full up and neck tone rolled off completely. This does not sound the same as reversing the tone settings, nor does it sound the same as tone full up on both. How could you get the same variation out of the VVT?
FWIW I am not making an argument for one over the other, in fact I have considered going VVT to simplify things (and to see if I miss the options.....).