• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fender or Squier?

My beef is with the necks. The wood used in making bodies may make subtle differeces in tone, but assuming the body balances the instrument, are of little consequence as to whether or not the instrument is playable. A twisted neck is a much more serious issue.

If someone wants to investigate body wood issues, have at it, and let us know what you find. I make my own basses at this point, partly because I can get very stable necks that way, so I’m not going to put much effort into investigating Fender or Squier body woods.
OK neck wood.
Again, if another manufacturer in your example PRS took Squier's neck wood and kiln dried it, it would be fine.
 
OK neck wood.
Again, if another manufacturer in your example PRS took Squier's neck wood and kiln dried it, it would be fine.

Yep. My advice on MIM’s and Squiers is to buy one a few years old - let the original owner take the risk that the neck will go bad. A 5 year old neck that’s straight is much more likely to stay that way than a new one in this case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4sight and DJ Bebop
OK neck wood.
Again, if another manufacturer in your example PRS took Squier's neck wood and kiln dried it, it would be fine.
It would be pretty much incomprehensible for a manufacturing plant to not use kiln dried wood that had been acclimatizing in their shop. Perhaps the high temperatures and humidity of Indonesia pump too much moisture back in after being kiln dried. Kiln drying is very different to roasting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dxb and DJ Bebop
If recovering money invested in Squire at resale is not a factor, Squires can be upgraded to a better bass. My go-to is a '76 Fender J. Also own a Squire fretless J with DiMarzio pick ups...poor man's Jaco. Love both basses. Each have equal value in my play arsenal.
 
Yep. My advice on MIM’s and Squiers is to buy one a few years old - let the original owner take the risk that the neck will go bad. A 5 year old neck that’s straight is much more likely to stay that way than a new one in this case.
Not buying. There are a gazillion really happy Squier and MIM owners out there, a bunch right here on this forum, with no consistent complaints, then there is you presenting yourself as an authority. Whatever your issue is with Squier or MIM don't exaggerate to make a point.

I do not currently own a Squier but would not hesitate if I found one that fit my needs. Matter of fact, if I run up on, what is now pretty hard to get all of your alleged issues aside, a Squier Cv 60's PBass I'd love to buy. Great bass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dxb and DJ Bebop
Thank you. I have a Lyon LB-40 (Washburn) I just would not let go of. It has a neck very close to a JB ooooh excellent I have come to find out. The body must be basswood, it is dull and seems soft just on it's own but just as punchy as any of them through an amp. I could never replace it for $300 so I'll just hang on to it.
I bought it at a Play It Again store about 8 years ago. Whoever had it cut the nut slots a good bit low and maybe five thousandths extra relief. The strings lay lower than any other bass I have seen but they don't buzz. And open vs 12th fret intonation is spot on, with believe it or not, most every fret intonated. It likes 40 - 95's and they stay on it.
 
Last edited:
Don't forget the Squier Classic Vibe. The Inca Silver and Lake Placid Blue Jazz basses are still available and you can find the new Sea Foam Pearl Precision at Guitar Center.
The Jazz models are getting harder and harder to find and the Precision is a limited edition.
Top of the line for Squier for a price that can't be beat.
View attachment 3239821
Do they make these in dark green? [the CV's] pawleeP