• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Finger Rest--- Sacrilegious on a P?

o4nsWMQl.jpg
 
It's not one of the first 100 P basses ever built - it's a Squire - a mass produced consumer product of which there are countless thousands in the wild. If it works better for you with a thumb rest (or any other mod) go ahead.
IMO, this is the fun of entry and mid-level guitars! Just have a ball and make yours. If it were going to be a collectors item one day, I could see an argument for being a little more cautious (and even then, at the end of the day, it's still yours so do what you want). Make the bass you want to play!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Artman
IMG_2405.jpeg
IMG_2404.jpeg
I sanded down the bottom edge of my thumb rest so that once it is screwed down, the thickness is about the same as the amount of pickup showing above the pickguard.
It feels more natural to me when I do use it than it did when it was at full thickness.

Do whatever you want with your own bass. You are the only person who has to play it.
Have fun!
 
I have a Squire P Bass. I fond that I miss the thumb rest. I had it on a Jazz bass I had previously (shown in the picture attached). Is it considered taboo to do this to a P. I mean I know it is my bass and all but......
Go for it, my prime playing spot is directly over the pickup. I try and not anchor my thumb , but it’s a hard habit to break.

Lately i have considered this ThumbRocker - Bass Pickup Thumb Rest - Fender Precision Style Pickups - No Holes | eBay

For my Squier Debut :)
 
As an eBay Associate, TalkBass may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.
I have a Squire P Bass. I fond that I miss the thumb rest. I had it on a Jazz bass I had previously (shown in the picture attached). Is it considered taboo to do this to a P. I mean I know it is my bass and all but......
Of course not. It's your bass. Do what you like.

Me? I find the traditional Fender thumb rest as placed above the E string near the end of the fingerboard to be nothing more than an encumbrance.

I find it way more comfortable to (a) anchor the bass with my forearm and float my thumb along the length of the E or (b) rest it against the corner/front side of the pickup. Why, because I enjoy the tactile proximity of thumb and fingertip. Having my thumb anchored on top of a thumb rest all the time would remove that.
 
I have a Squire P Bass. I fond that I miss the thumb rest. I had it on a Jazz bass I had previously (shown in the picture attached). Is it considered taboo to do this to a P. I mean I know it is my bass and all but......
I put thumb rests on any bass that I want to. Sacrilegious? Who cares. Only thinking makes it so. (Thanks Will.)
These are attached with double sided tape. There is a small notch that sits on the corner of pickup that is just enough to stop downward pressure from moving the thumb rest over time.
My Two Home Made Basses.JPG
 
Last edited:
Of course not. It's your bass. Do what you like.

Me? I find the traditional Fender thumb rest as placed above the E string near the end of the fingerboard to be nothing more than an encumbrance.

I find it way more comfortable to (a) anchor the bass with my forearm and float my thumb along the length of the E or (b) rest it against the corner/front side of the pickup. Why, because I enjoy the tactile proximity of thumb and fingertip. Having my thumb anchored on top of a thumb rest all the time would remove that.
The forearm rest is no help with this bass, lol:
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2817.jpeg
    IMG_2817.jpeg
    851.9 KB · Views: 9
Yes, they were stock in the mid-70's. I owned a few that came that way from Fender. I have a similar issue. My first p basses came with the ashtray covers factory installed. I am so used to using the pickup cover as a thumb rest that I automatically wing up putting my hand there. Solution? Just put one on. Bridge cover? Well, one without the other is like wearing a shirt with no pants!

BBB

1726106044698.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: antfarm and Dan1985