Andras Szalay
Commercial User
>> I would have assumed that the release would be triggered by a 'note off' command.
This is true.
>> The user could then adjust the note off parameter to a level before tracking became an issue.
This is not true. To decide when a note off should be issued is a very complicated process, not a simple decision based on the signal level. I cannot go into details here, but e.g. if you stop a loud, very short note then the signal level when the note off must be issued is probably 100 times larger than in a long sustained note.
I explained why a RELEASE is missing (or better, it is set automatical); retriggering is a completely separate issue. If I remember well it was a request from AKAI that during continuous play the attack should not be restarted. I did not mind, as it is quite natural for guitar playing, but technically it would not be complicated to implement. Of course I can think about this only as an optional possibility, so it would require new parameter in the data structure, this could be much more complicated, this is why also the flexi controllers are not yet released.
Andras Szalay
This is true.
>> The user could then adjust the note off parameter to a level before tracking became an issue.
This is not true. To decide when a note off should be issued is a very complicated process, not a simple decision based on the signal level. I cannot go into details here, but e.g. if you stop a loud, very short note then the signal level when the note off must be issued is probably 100 times larger than in a long sustained note.
I explained why a RELEASE is missing (or better, it is set automatical); retriggering is a completely separate issue. If I remember well it was a request from AKAI that during continuous play the attack should not be restarted. I did not mind, as it is quite natural for guitar playing, but technically it would not be complicated to implement. Of course I can think about this only as an optional possibility, so it would require new parameter in the data structure, this could be much more complicated, this is why also the flexi controllers are not yet released.
Andras Szalay