• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Get off my LAWN! "Grumpy Old Farts"

Status
Not open for further replies.
Long Friday opening day of my gig, 14 hours with an early Saturday morning start. This used to be so much easier when I was younger!
It only seemed easier...you're just getting too old to accurately remember what it was really like when you were younger. :thumbsup:
 
...sorry if I offend anyone, but someone is going to have talk very slowly and make one heck of argument for me to understand how the "everyone gets a participation trophy" approach to teaching children prepares them for the world they are going to be living in.
My degree is in Child Development.
Children's minds are developing.
Try, not cry.
Resilience is needed
Later life will teach you enough about defeat.
No need to hurry it along.
 
My degree is in Child Development.
Children's minds are developing.
Try, not cry.
Resilience is needed
Later life will teach you enough about defeat.
No need to hurry it along.
Sounds like my education and life experiences are the furthest thing from your's, but I really do appreciate your point. I think there is a fine line between allowing failure and discouragement to create a victim/loser mind-set and having folks see that everyone brings a strength to the party, but your strength may not always be the one in demand that day or you may not be the strongest at that party. I suspect that somewhere in that poorly expressed thought is the teachable moment set-up for a discussion of teamwork and learning to focus on others rather than only on self.

Some really bad outcomes (business, cultural, and personal) have resulted from cut-throat competition and an all too familiar "need to win at all costs" mentality. However, competition can be a great way to benchmark yourself and learn where you need to improve. Clearly the younger the individual, the more care is needed to guide those developmental experiences from insightful, caring folks with your skills. IME we often learn more from our valley experiences in life than we do from our mountain top moments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alaskaleftybass
Sounds like my education and life experiences are the furthest thing from your's, but I really do appreciate your point. I think there is a fine line between allowing failure and discouragement to create a victim/loser mind-set and having folks see that everyone brings a strength to the party, but your strength may not always be the one in demand that day or you may not be the strongest at that party. I suspect that somewhere in that poorly expressed thought is the teachable moment set-up for a discussion of teamwork and learning to focus on others rather than only on self.

Some really bad outcomes (business, cultural, and personal) have resulted from cut-throat competition and an all too familiar "need to win at all costs" mentality. However, competition can be a great way to benchmark yourself and learn where you need to improve. Clearly the younger the individual, the more care is needed to guide those developmental experiences from insightful, caring folks with your skills. IME we often learn more from our valley experiences in life than we do from our mountain top moments.
Well put, @Al Kraft . Very young children need to learn competition, but in a sportsmanlike way, to learn teamwork and to learn how to win or lose graciously. The fact that schools are creating "everyone's a winner in competition" is horse pucky to me. There is a thrill in winning and a lesson in losing. Playing for the team is very important. And yes, learning how to contribute your strengths and recognizing other's strengths is important. Like old Mr. Toupe Howard Coselle said, "the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat..."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Al Kraft
My degree is in Child Development.
Children's minds are developing.
Try, not cry.
Resilience is needed
Later life will teach you enough about defeat.
No need to hurry it along.

I suspect that somewhere in that poorly expressed thought is the teachable moment set-up for a discussion of teamwork and learning to focus on others rather than only on self.
Succinct.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Al Kraft
That is exactly where the failure is IMO. Morality. It certainly can't be legislated. It needs to be taught. Schools are forbidden and most churches are NPO's and therefor forbidden. That leaves parants, which usually both have a job or two. So that leaves baby sitters. Kids teaching morality to kids. Shuddup kid, I'm txt'ing. Change your own damned diaper.
 
That is exactly where the failure is IMO. Morality. It certainly can't be legislated. It needs to be taught. Schools are forbidden and most churches are NPO's and therefor forbidden. That leaves parants, which usually both have a job or two. So that leaves baby sitters. Kids teaching morality to kids. Shuddup kid, I'm txt'ing. Change your own damned diaper.
Our societal/cultural/family structure and parenting CONOPS (to use a military phrase) is having a deleterious effect on our next generation of adults IMO. You really can't blame a kid for their lack of being parented. Sadly though, society will later hold them accountable for behaviors that manifest from those early lessons not learned. When raising kids, somebody needs to be the parent and that role is distinctly different from (albeit complementary with) the roles of teacher, coach, rabbi/priest/minister, peer, friend, mentor, etc. FWIW I firmly believe that none of the functionality of those roles can be found on a smartphone, TV, or even a laptop/desktop computer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BadExample
There's fairness in winning but also fairness in losing.

I was just talking with a friend about horse show fairness. I was turned off years ago when I saw the winners on the judges clipboard before the class even started. Worse, the winner had scratched the class. That's not losing, it's called getting stuffed.
 
Gymnastics, figure skating, and other subjectively judged sports have had scandals. Then there were Russians that had sex changes to gain an advantage, not to mention how many push the boundaries with drugs. I can see horse events having some of that. Both drugs and corruption.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.