• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

GHS Balanced Nickel strings

Are balanced RC Boomers available now, if I order a set will it come in the "balanced" set? Thanks again!

The new construction RC Bass Boomers are out, but they're still in "traditional" sets (45-65-85-105, etc..), which are still better balanced than they were. At this point, if you want a truly balanced set, you need to order singles.
 
The new construction RC Bass Boomers are out, but they're still in "traditional" sets (45-65-85-105, etc..), which are still better balanced than they were. At this point, if you want a truly balanced set, you need to order singles.

Ooo, I like my RC Boomers. A (closer to) balanced set would be amazing.
Edit: Not that I've particularly noticed any balance issues on the older RCB set I have on my Jazz bass.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: FirewalZ
Black or silver silks would go with any color or natural finish bass.

Like this?

HBPJLC4JNfO-FKV5VKq6FH2UqacZEyK2Gs-sO0TF_iKeEbNFDX8TeYFj6Yh7HsGQ_09UvsT7Gew6mIwid31M47RVCRaiwBd2GXx6XgybgI09YimFNDSf7N8JCZIvVKZmNFgAIvk9Utf78QSH-wmr0kKljGkw6y1GmfZy9HT0LCeHpFNPx64URcOmeYDyuzbdYNPWDQoJK5IKuYYtbEp-A7kwV6vTR4hE0wqtXec5PQ9ZzymjkS19Leu50KBUjas4ha3kIipaqloI78cm1Do9JkKHq5T_hw3WElizvxlaoS6ciYAuD0_K0iAM2YY6lDVV-UE3vl7O9RxA6jmZs7C911FMNIfHod9dIfafQxH_XjCXFJikPgws0qFvUXw6IAszntBHxBu6d6qoY69XwjhQkp_JWO_t-gv9iEUBepRXbKyTj1m9LnRmqois7iKo9f_6FyQ4oN0Ao57yZit2v566EvwIxOBFjewbkHmc6ZlhXIa7lH8-UOpShuslNU3jWsSe2V26xUZngrSkwpZjWFbKB6s_1ZfL7fxLI7LaQxMMmcp2fg5nuOdfAmyr6-E2bu45wWgZ7YokviFk0LL-fZVbD6R35Eb7xB8tpeY8z4-dk_5IdhmKnpF6mqJl1EP6-C47WFrMiEuTuI6GHnSUzKCqQAc3bjXMEdB6UncOMZrYHIY_12PBtGotcoI=w362-h644-no
 
I can’t bring myself to get caught up in the color of the silk, when I care so much more about the tone and playability of the strings. The GHS Nickel Balanced strings hit the mark for me, whether the silks are green, black, or neon orange.

Agreed about the silk color being such a small part of the whole scheme of things.

Then again, there are those of us who suffer from a condition commonly known as OCD. :D
 
Indeed, I highly doubt that I would hit the minimum quantity order, but just out of curiosity, what is the minimum quantity?

1 gross. Pretty easy for builders (and we do a lot of custom strings for them), but not for the player.
 
Is the general consensus here that the GHS BN or a 'firmer touch/stiffer' than DR Sunbeams?

(Im enjoying the BN more than the Sunbeams but if memory serves, I feel like Sunbeams were 'stiffer' me)

I gig with two identical 5 strings, one still has the DR rounds cores on it, and I decided to try the BN on the other one; the BN are stiffer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NKBassman
Wow! this is an amazing explanation. Bump.

Yes i suspect D'Addario and Kalium also just carefully measure the unit weight, then use that and scale and pitch in the equation to get tension.

To go into deeper detail, that string equation is based on an assumption of a 'perfect string' with zero stiffness.
However no need to be alarmed by this as bass strings are actually, in terms of this assumption, very flexible, their stiffness has a quite insignificant effect on the tension result.

If you think about how wobbly a bass string is when you dangle it from your hand, and how easy it is to bend very slightly in your hands, there is almost no resistance. Compare this resistance to the huge tension that is applied when on the instrument, it is fairly insignificant.

How a linear object vibrates depends on its tension and its stiffness and the balance of those.

At one extreme is a vibraphone with zero tension and high stiffness (solid metal bars), when struck the 'restoring force' acting against the deformation of the bar is entirely due to stiffness.
The frequencies of the harmonics are very different from those of a guitar string.

At the other extreme is guitars with very low stiffness and high tension, when struck the 'restoring force' acting against the deformation of the string is almost entirely due to tension.
The frequencies of the harmonics are what we consider 'harmonic', being 1x 2x 3x 4x 5x ... the fundamental frequency.

So what is the effect of stiffness on the tension of a (bass)guitar string?
Stiffness acts as additional 'restoring force' and therefore raises pitch. To return to the desired pitch you then have to reduce tension a little. So the actual tension at desired pitch is a slightly lower than the result of the basic equation, but not by a significant amount and not enough to be bothered with when calculating tensions. Scientific equipment to accurately measure stiffness is rare and expensive, whereas unit weight just requires an accurate weighing machine, weigh 34" of string and divide by 34.

Stiffness in a guitar string also shifts the frequencies of the harmonics, causing 'inharmonicity', that 'out of tune with itself' tone you get when playing a B or E string on the highest frets. Playing a fat string on the high frets effectively raises the stiffness, and therefore pitch, meaning the scale length needs to be increased to acheive the desired pitch, this is why we offset the saddle position away from the nut to intonate a string, and the offset is larger for stiffer strings. As you play up the frets the intonation offset becomes larger relative to the length of the string, to provide an increasing compensation.
 
I've got to say that I absolutely love the GHS BN strings on my Fender American Special PBass! I actually love them so much I'll probably end up with them on my other 2 basses also. Both are PBasses. IMO these are the best strings made hands down!

I agree!
I have them on 3 of my basses. I have 100's of hours on one set and I see no reason to put new ones on.