• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Gig Bag or HSC

I had a few basses in HSC’s stacked against the wall with a loaded gig bag on top. Not paying attention one day and stumbled into the stack and as i tried to recover i stepped back and heard a crack. Turns out the gig bag slipped off the stack and i stepped on the neck just below the headstock and broke the neck. Still use gig bags but only if i’m taking a bass and a combo amp. Any more gear or an overnight trip and it’s an HSC.
 
When you go to a gig or practice. Do you use your gig bag or HSC. Guess I'm wondering if you trust the gig bag.

It depends on how particular you are, where you are gigging and how you are getting there.

Me, I am too particular, I always use a hardshell case.

If I were going to use a bag, it would have to be heavily padded, not on of those that you get with a new bass.

If I had such a bag, I would only carry it if I were in my own vehicle and could make I could place it on top and know that nothing would shift around(there are no guarantees of this, so I use a case).

After a gig is when I would always choose a case over a bag because after I hit the last note, off comes the strap and in the case it goes. I set the case next to a wall where it's least likely to be knocked over and stepped on. Then I can break down everything else.

The only things I like about is you can throw them over your shoulder and if you are doing small gigs where you are toting a light amp. Toting them upstairs is easier over the shoulder too.
 
I’ll 3rd the Gator Go Pro gig bag. These things are great. Can say I’ve tried the double one but it looks solid as well. They also stand up on their own. Which I put off to the side at gigs. Wallet, phone, key ect go in the top pocket so I can keep an eye on them. And I’ve never had a bass get damaged in mine. Had mine for over 2 years. And I gig over 40 times a year. No strap, zipper issues. No tears inside or out. Even the price is reasonable.

For air travel I have a “flight case”. Hence the name.
 
It’s not the pounds first and foremost - it’s a combination of the weight, the format, the lack of carrying options, lack of storage space and the sheer inconvienience of the thing. And if you use a Mono, or any of the other premium gig bags, the protection is as good or better for any situation except one, and that is being crushed by a heavy weight. Which is totally avoidable if you’re careful, which is frankly what you should be anyway.
Whatever works for ya! :thumbsup: