• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Has Gretsch been lying to us for over a decade?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was referencing Asher Platts post regarding Gretsch having no liability. My reply, which you’re quoting, was to gin1955 who asked me to spell out what my suspicions were regarding Asher Platts post.

What are you talking about?

that was exactly what i was talking about. what don't you understand? why do you think this dude would make up this story ? in a thread with countless similar stories, when he has his story documented and dated from 1-2 years ago?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bpc and Glazenn
So... a number of people here, and on the FB Shortscale bass group, returned their single coil models -- to Sweetwater no less -- only to receive ... another single coil model. Because they are all single coil models. And not only are they all single coils, it's Cap'n Crunch's "Oops! All bridge pickups!" so they have the same polarity, and no hums are canceled.
VAPORGRAM1650384331971.jpg
 
that was exactly what i was talking about. what don't you understand? why do you think this dude would make up this story ? in a thread with countless similar stories, when he has his story documented and dated from 1-2 years ago?

A) how was I to know that he has a related story he posted somewhere else 2 years ago

and

B) having all bridge pickups isn’t the same thing as saying (per LE Lobster) they’re actually single coils rather than mini humbuckers like Gretsch is currently advertising.

Sorry if my post inadvertently triggered you somehow.
 
that was exactly what i was talking about. what don't you understand? why do you think this dude would make up this story ? in a thread with countless similar stories, when he has his story documented and dated from 1-2 years ago?
A ringer for WHOM?

What is my motive exactly? (I know you aren't saying this but the people you are responding to are, and it's bananapants).

Honestly ask yourself a question: when lots of people notice the same problem, and then it's confirmed visually in two different places two years apart, (the LEL video, and the photo of my own pickups) which is more likely?

That a massive corporation was cutting corners and is trying to cover it up?

Or that all the confirmed instances of this are actually fake and we are all paid agents for ... who exactly?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bpc
Great comment. I agree. This isn't about egregious damages suffered by customers, this is about making things right with your customers. Nobody's died or gotten injured over this (though I did almost cut my thumb opening up the pickup heheh), but that doesn't mean that there's not an issue here nor does it mean it shouldn't be resolved because it's not a 'big deal'. Consumer protection laws exist for a reason, and it's within our rights as customers to receive what's advertised and to leverage those laws when we do not. The price tier of the instrument or perceived quality doesn't matter here. Your Joycon example is wonderful, and thank you for bringing it up. Joycons are like $80 USD, yet there was an issue that was identified by consumers, reported on, and rectified appropriately. It's not unreasonable to expect Fender/Gretsch to do the same. Whether or not it will happen is another story entirely, but I don't believe we are acting entitled or are in the wrong for expecting trusted brands like Gretsch/Fender to deliver an instrument as advertised... regardless of price.

I disagree about this example being good. The joycon drift actually caused problems that made playing games difficult to impossible. When the entire point of the system is to play games something that makes that difficult would be a large issue. A similar bass problem would be pots that drifted by themselves while playing. That would cause significant issues with playing the bass.
 
I disagree about this example being good. The joycon drift actually caused problems that made playing games difficult to impossible. When the entire point of the system is to play games something that makes that difficult would be a large issue. A similar bass problem would be pots that drifted by themselves while playing. That would cause significant issues with playing the bass.
subjective. the games i played on switch were not affected at all by joycon drift .. however, hum on my bass would greatly impact my recordings and one of the biggest things i try to avoid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bpc
Because he posted it in on this thread? Not my fault you didn't bother to read before calling out/accusing someone . It's not like he has many posts here (right?) You gonna call someone out at least bother to read what he says first? Or get called out yourself.
The link to my review on my blog should also be in my signature, on every single one of my posts.
 
This is getting ridiculous.
Who cares what Mr. Platt does with his time and career? C'mon guys.
Since people don't seem to believe that I actually owned, played, recorded, and gigged with this bass, allow me to produce more bonafides:

here is a promotional photo for one of my bands, adlt grrrl
123466221_114226193817588_2969685133482732094_n.jpg


Source here:

That's also my Gretsch drumset. I used to think Gretsch was pretty swell.

I recorded our first EP, "Personal Best", with that bass.



I really loved playing that bass, it was small, so I could move around more quickly, and frankly it had that rumbling punchy tone that I love from Chris Squire's rickosound Rickenbacker, but I don't make that kind of money, and I find Rick's to be neckdivey anyways (but that tone tho, *chef kiss*)

All I wanted was humbucker pickups in a short scale bass. Instead I got a year long battle with Fender customer service who insisted that I was wrong and refused to do anything to fix it, and then again, I cannot emphasize this enough, they destroyed my bass by cutting off the headstock and then still did not give me a refund for months: it was only after I threatened to sue and started cc-ing the Attorney General Consumer Fraud email on my communications that they cut me a check.
 
Settle down, little one. I merely find it interesting that you show up here less than 24 hours ago and every single post you've made has been in this thread alone. That's fine, that's dandy. But please, don't insult our intelligence by feigning ignorance.

You're an activist, I get it. You've seen an opportunity, I get that too. But STOP PRETENDING your "contributions" to this thread are anything else but political opportunism.

And, man! Don't I wish I was a "paid Fender rep"! :)

EDIT: And it can hardly be considered "doxing" when, as you stated previously, your extraneous information is in your sig.

Ashen uses foil to shield his bass hum. You use foil to make little hats.
 
Because he posted it in on this thread? Not my fault you didn't bother to read before calling out/accusing someone . It's not like he has many posts here (right?) You gonna call someone out at least bother to read what he says first? Or get called out yourself.

Whatever.

I simply aired my suspicion and admitted I was curious to another member. Hardly the same thing as calling someone out.

FWIW I’ve been on TB a long time. And who I am and where I’m coming from is well known to enough folks here that I’m sure not too many of them are going to take the ball and run it the way you are. So feel free to call me out at will.

And that’s all I’ve got to say.

Be well. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.