Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
How long has it been since you last broke a string?
- Thread starter rockdoc11
- Start date
The last E string I broke was broken twenty years ago, which is quite strange because I still play the bass with a hard attack...
i've never broken a bass string.. i've had a couple flats unwind themselves while doing a swap from one bass to another, but that was 40-ish years ago, and was 100% operator error.
- Oct 22, 2015
- 21,164
- 256,784
- Disclosures
- I am an affiliate for Ari Cap.
1986 - last note of our last song at the battle of the bands my senior year of high school. Crowd was digging us, we were rocking all original material, and I was playing way too hard. Hit that final big crescendo and it gave up the ghost. One of the few “just like a movie” moments I’ve had in my life.
Except we did not win, which is how I knew it was not really a movie...
Except we did not win, which is how I knew it was not really a movie...
So may years ago, I don't even know.
I've only had maybe two strings break in 38 years... and when they did it was because there were burrs dug into the bridge saddle....
I've only had maybe two strings break in 38 years... and when they did it was because there were burrs dug into the bridge saddle....
I broke one string in almost 50 years of playing. It was sometime in the 80's. I don't even remember which string it was. I was playing my pre CBS 62 Fender jazz with a Badass II bridge. I have no clue what brand of strings I was using. I had no spares and no spare bass. Lucky for me the sound guy had his Fender jazz backstage, and quickly brought it out to me after we finished the current song. He put a new string on my bass from his spare set and got it back to me after one song... And the show went on...
Once ever about 15 years ago in the last 20 years. Due to a burr on the saddle probably.
Oh and once when I attached two strings to a piece of 1 by lumber as a school science project. I must’ve over tightened it or something.
Oh and once when I attached two strings to a piece of 1 by lumber as a school science project. I must’ve over tightened it or something.
I broke one about 35 years ago due to a burr on a bridge saddle. That's it for BG strings.
About 20 years ago I had two DB strings break due to poor QC...they broke at the wrappings above the nut...so I switched brands and have not had a break since then.
About 20 years ago I had two DB strings break due to poor QC...they broke at the wrappings above the nut...so I switched brands and have not had a break since then.
When I first started playing and had no technique. Heavy pick, light strings.
Most recently changing strings, must have been a wonky one because it snapped.
Most recently changing strings, must have been a wonky one because it snapped.
D
When actually playing: around 1992/93 when I still used a pick and played METAL, lol.
During setup: 3 times the last couple of weeks thanks to the useless new fluted tuning machines on the Fender American Professional series. It's the G-string that breaks, again and again. Unless you leave enough string length to fill the entire tuning post those fluted shafts will pull the string downwards and create far too much tension at the angle where the string goes into the tuning post. Seriously, if you need to fill up the tuning post with windings to avoid breaking the string, WHAT'S THE POINT??? Useless piece of junk. This is just Fender trying to fix a problem that isn't really there. If they had simply installed a string tree for the A-string the whole issue about tension over the nut would be non-existent.
Strings where the total uncut length of the G-string won't give you more than 2-3 windings on the tuning posts (like TI Superalloys) simply can't be trusted with these new fluted Fender tuning machines. I broke three Superalloy G-strings during setup and then just gave up.
So thanks Fender for ruining three sets of Superalloys with your useless and completely unneccessary "innovations". It's a shame really, because I absolutely love the sound of Superalloys + the V-mod pickup.
During setup: 3 times the last couple of weeks thanks to the useless new fluted tuning machines on the Fender American Professional series. It's the G-string that breaks, again and again. Unless you leave enough string length to fill the entire tuning post those fluted shafts will pull the string downwards and create far too much tension at the angle where the string goes into the tuning post. Seriously, if you need to fill up the tuning post with windings to avoid breaking the string, WHAT'S THE POINT??? Useless piece of junk. This is just Fender trying to fix a problem that isn't really there. If they had simply installed a string tree for the A-string the whole issue about tension over the nut would be non-existent.
Strings where the total uncut length of the G-string won't give you more than 2-3 windings on the tuning posts (like TI Superalloys) simply can't be trusted with these new fluted Fender tuning machines. I broke three Superalloy G-strings during setup and then just gave up.
So thanks Fender for ruining three sets of Superalloys with your useless and completely unneccessary "innovations". It's a shame really, because I absolutely love the sound of Superalloys + the V-mod pickup.
Pbassmanca
In the pocket n' thumpy. So woody, so greasy...
You can't beat the thick punch of those thick strings!Exactly never
BUT I've only been playing (nearly everyday) since 2013, and I've gravitated towards the 55-110 sets in the past year+
While gigging I would break one string sometimes, 80’s through early 90’s.
I’m not sure but I believe once I began session work, I haven’t broken a string since.
I used to play extremely hard but now I pay pretty darn light and use the power of the amp.
I’m not sure but I believe once I began session work, I haven’t broken a string since.
I used to play extremely hard but now I pay pretty darn light and use the power of the amp.
25 years ago (or so) I broke a string on my first bass while tuning it (I overtightened the D string), then never since.
NEVER broke a bass string, but I've only been playing bass "full time" for about 7-8 years.
(Kinda sporadically filling in / noodling for 25ish years, when I was more of a full time drummer/guitarist )
(Kinda sporadically filling in / noodling for 25ish years, when I was more of a full time drummer/guitarist )
