• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I don't mean to be rude

I believe in live and let live, but I agree with the OP and am not a fan of a white pickguard on a sunburst bass. Black or tort for me. So, I added a few stickers on mine to make it more palatable until I get a chance to make a new one.
IMG_20240303_143616811.jpg
 
I don’t mean to be rude, by why a pickguard at all? Why spend the time and money to do a sunburst finish that shows wood grain just to cover it with a cheap piece of plastic? It’s the most ridiculous “tradition” in the music world. It’s tacky like wood paneling on cars and plastic on furniture… thank goodness those fads died. Now we’ve just gotta get rid of this ridiculous pickguard epidemic.

Is rear routing so hard so we don’t have to use cheap plastic to cover top routes? Oh the humanity! I weep for the nice finishes destroyed by pickguards and top routes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phreaky Phriday
I don’t mean to be rude, by why a pickguard at all? Why spend the time and money to do a sunburst finish that shows wood grain just to cover it with a cheap piece of plastic? It’s the most ridiculous “tradition” in the music world. It’s tacky like wood paneling on cars and plastic on furniture… thank goodness those fads died. Now we’ve just gotta get rid of this ridiculous pickguard epidemic.

Is rear routing so hard so we don’t have to use cheap plastic to cover top routes? Oh the humanity! I weep for the nice finishes destroyed by pickguards and top routes.
In practice all but the finest basses would then have a cheap plastic cover in the rear which looks worse IMHO.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MattZilla
I don’t mean to be rude, by why a pickguard at all? Why spend the time and money to do a sunburst finish that shows wood grain just to cover it with a cheap piece of plastic? It’s the most ridiculous “tradition” in the music world. It’s tacky like wood paneling on cars and plastic on furniture… thank goodness those fads died. Now we’ve just gotta get rid of this ridiculous pickguard epidemic.

Is rear routing so hard so we don’t have to use cheap plastic to cover top routes? Oh the humanity! I weep for the nice finishes destroyed by pickguards and top routes.

You raise a good point.
 
This one's definitely a repro, my Sire D5 I got myself in memory of my brother's bass...

View attachment 5395838

Would really like a straight white pg on it though!

Update - just snagged the last white one on ebay at the moment, I think! ;)
Sire keeps on amazing me more and more !
The look is so nice, finition seems perfect and their necks with the roll edges are just so comfortable !
Unbelievable for the price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bholder
Sire keeps on amazing me more and more !
The look is so nice, finition seems perfect and their necks with the roll edges are just so comfortable !
Unbelievable for the price.
Yup. I'm a Sire fan from way back at the start, but these new models and the Gen 2 neck treatments are just out of this world! Bang per buck for miles and miles!
 
Similarly, I don’t dig the white PG on my ‘08 LPB Squier CV 50s P, even though I know white is probably “right” for LPB. Feels like I should be playing surf tunes (not that there’s anything wrong with that…)

The finish/route under the guard is good enough to leave it off, but I hate the holes more than I hate the white, so I’ll just leave it on there until I get motivated to paint it or get a custom. (I’d ask if anyone with the same bass in butterscotch wants to swap my white PG for your black, but white on ‘scotch would be even more bizarre.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: winojunko