• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I turned off my bass......nobody noticed!

:help:

I just had what I think was the worst gig of my life. I could go on and on about the hundreds of things that went wrong or bothered me but I want to focus on one thing that I feel is just rediculous.

I'll do a little set up so you know where I am coming from.

Incoming Wall Of Text!!!!!!!

I play in a three piece cover band. (We have four members but one is a singer/part time keyboardist, so I consider it three peice.) We play a mix of new and older rock toons. Any thing from AC/DC to Paramore, Foo Fighters to Deep Purple. We have three singers. Myself (the bass player, male), the guitarist (male), and a female vocalist (the guitarists wife.) We all sing back up for each other. The songs are split pretty even at 1/3 per singer.

I feel we have some of the best talent in the area. I am not saying we are awesome, just above average for what we do. I think everyone has good tones for their instruments. We know how to sound good together (so I thought!) and no one is a diva. We all work together very well and have for a long time. We are all very close friends and have been for years.

A few months ago we added another member to our band by hiring a full time sound man. (Previously, we (I) ran everything from stage. We own our own P.A.) Everyone really likes him and it has taken a large load off my shoulders having someone there that can do the dirty work. The other band members often rave about how good we sound now and I love being able to concentrate on singing and playing and not sound problems/issues.

O.K., thats the background, here is the issue.

I became concerned that I (meaning my bass not vocals)have not been in the mix during our last few shows. I thought maybe I was getting a little too much bleed though from the stage volume. No big deal, I'll turn down. I started looking at the board closer on the next few gigs. It looked fishy to me. I asked, "Am, I too loud on stage?" The sound man says no. My band-mates say "No, turn it up a bit." They can't hear me, but only if I ask. :hmm:

So to test my theory, on the last gig, I shut the volume controls on my bass guitar off during a few songs. ( No signal to the board, no signal to my amp!) These were not your typical root note bashing song, but song that I think had good bass lines that are important to the song or walking bass lines that should be missed if gone. The songs would/should have sound very sterile if the bass was not there.

Nobody noticed! Not my drummer, not the guitarist or other singer, not my wife or my daughter who were both in the audience and seated directly in front of me, and most imprortant, not the sound guy! However, later in the night, my guitardist stepped on his cord and pulled it out from the jack. Everyone noticed that!

I pride myself on being a good solid bass player. I know my job. I try to never overplay anything. I have good timing. I pay attention to the drummer and his lead. I know that the bass guitar is not the "sexy" intrument. I make sure my tone is "right" for the song,"right" for the band, and "right" for the room. I stay out of the guitar players frequency bed. (But I do not always get the same treatment.) I do my best to compliment the drums.

I do not know what to do at this point. I am screaming mad about this and I do not think I can even discuss it with my bandmates without it becoming a full blown fight.

I refuse to be just an average player. I practice long and hard. I have hundreds of gigs and experience under my belt. If I am not going to be heard, or worse, not missed when I am gone, I do not see the need to be in this band.

A three peice band with no bass guitar? NO! NO! NO! How can no one notice that one of the three is missing unless everone is used no not hearing me in the first place?

I must have miss-judged my ability and worth somewhere along the line. It's the only explaination that I can come up with.

Anyways, I am at my lowest point. I feel disgusted and depressed. I may be looking for something new.

:confused::(:bawl::scowl::mad:
 
Hmm. I play in a 4 piece and if I turned my bass off we wouldn't get two bars before someone would be looking at me with a *** look. I don't know what to tell you, but there sure needs to be a band meeting with the sound guy.
 
I wouldn't even waste anymore time with them (but I quit a band during the middle of a two weekend recording session because instead of asking me to lay down a simpler bass line for one song....the lead guitarist recorded a new bass line while I wasn't there.....dropped them like a hot effing rock).

I don't know.....maybe you probably should say something in a few days after you've cooled your jets. That's probably what I should have done. YMMV.
 
Just read your post and don't have a clue as to what you're talking about...and we do want to help.

As Joe Friday use to say: "just the facts, ma'am".

Riis

How do you not have a clue what the OP is talking about? It's pretty clear to me. He turned his bass off, and no one could tell the difference. He feels pretty undervalued and underappreciated as a result. Are you sure you can read?

As for the OP, I'm sorry about what happened. It sucks to play with musicians who don't listen to anything but themselves. The sound guy doesn't seem to listen very well either. Move on, is my advice. These types of musicians don't usually change in my experience. For god's sake if you are going to bring it up with them do not get all pissed off and angry. That will make you feel even worse, and won't resolve anything.
 
Ok. Some seams confused about this.

I turned myself OFF! On stage, while playing. No signal whatsoever. Not to my amp, not to the P.A. No one noticed! Not the sound guy, not my band mates, not my family in the audience.

I don't know how to be more clear.

Bass to me is only behind vocals and drumming in importance when playing live music. I don't think I am being arrogant in saying that.

How can no one notice if it is gone? Am I, as a bass player, just super sensitive to the lower frequencies of the bass guitar?
 
So where is all the low end coming from? If you were playing songs where the root of each guitar chord is played by the bass, for the most part, this is easy to believe. Too much low end coming from the guitar rig. EDIT: I see you have keys. That's where I'd look first. Keys players are notorious for 1) playing too much and 2)too much low-end in their sound.
 
People are right, there is either too much low from other instruments, you're not loud enough to begin with, or your amp has got smiley-face syndrome..

Your sound guy is supposed to be putting each instrument in their place (sonically) and making sure everyone can be heard. Its either the PA is too small and adding your bass in causes everything to get flubby, or the sound guy has no idea what he is doing at all.

Your post was clear, some just don't like reading more than a paragraph on a forum...
 
So where is all the low end coming from? If you were playing songs where the root of each guitar chord is played by the bass, for the most part, this is easy to believe. Too much low end coming from the guitar rig. EDIT: I see you have keys. That's where I'd look first. Keys players are notorious for 1) playing too much and 2)too much low-end in their sound.

No keys where being played in these songs. It must have been a combo of the kick, low tom and guitar cabs. Still unbeleivable that no one can notice when the bass line is missing from songs that are bass line dominant! (Meaning I was not following the guitar player, I had my own stuff going on.)
 
So where is all the low end coming from? If you were playing songs where the root of each guitar chord is played by the bass, for the most part, this is easy to believe. Too much low end coming from the guitar rig. EDIT: I see you have keys. That's where I'd look first. Keys players are notorious for 1) playing too much and 2)too much low-end in their sound.

+1. Problem may not be your lack of volume but rather the "frequency wars" which occur @ ~ 125 hz. A good soundman can fix it at the board but has virtually no control over your backline.

Riis
 
I was going to say, next time turn WAY up. I looked at your profile so see what amp & cab you use. Are you using the Carvin Red Eye 2x10 Combo into the PA? May be they have never really heard you and have gotten use to playing over you. Time for a SVT & 810, they will know when you drop out then.