• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is there realy any need for huge rigs?

If you don't mind carrying the amp,
then no one else should tell you to get the newest lightweight fad,
ever.

You pay the bills, they don't. I can't STAND it when people bash someone else for having a 50 pound head or a 200 pound cab,
who cares? It's their rig, not yours.

I tend to play better when I can really feel and hear myself. Its just a confidence thing, I'm more confident because I can tell what's coming out of my bass better than just guessing, or god forbid, telling everyone I don't "need to hear it."

There are amps for a reason, use the big ones if you want.

Amen to that!

My rig is a shadow of what it once was, since I'm currently don't have any bass gigs. I had a GK backline 600 and a peavey TX 810. If I had to choose between that and my peavey 1x15 combo I would choose the 8x10 rig in a heartbeat, and for the same reasons as mrkreuzschlitz.
 
When I was very young :cool:

I did a ton of gigs with 2 4x10s and 2 1x15s
2 800RBs (to give you a sign of the time)

Hey it was in cool at that time and we had help.
My how things changed. :p:hiding::p
 
And I'm not talking kids...I'm talking ALL age groups.

I'm not surprised the oldies like it loud too...

when my wife and I go to gigs with my parents-in-law (they're rockers too), it's ME that the one with the earplugs... they like it louder than me

I think it's because her parents' hearing must be even more damaged than mine is, so they need more volume just to hear anything at all

rock-induced hearing loss is maybe romantic as a purely abstract concept, but the reality of it is pretty far from desirable... I woke up one morning a few weeks ago with an awful ringing in my right ear, and was worried that this is it, the loud music's finally caught up, but it subsided & it must have been caused by something else... but when you face the prospect of permanent tinnitus.. it's not very rock'n'roll

anyway, I've wandered way off course... so to sum up... yes I have a large rig (oo-er missus) but I always wear uber-strength earplugs
 
I've been playing in bands for 30 years, some loud, some quiet, playing at tiny bars ("there's room for the band over there, if you move the pool table") to large stages.

I remember a time long ago when rock music was meant to be played loud and with an attitude. From the stage as well as through the PA. I recall one gig where our agent sent us to some little dive country bar (back when Hank Williams SR was on the jukebox) out in a vast remote wasteland. Well, we brought in our whole outdoor PA (two double 18" scoops on each side, etc. etc. etc.) and I brought in the fridge with the SVT head. This was one of those "move the pool table to fit" bars.

We thought we'd stick it to our agent for sending us to musical Siberia by cranking our volume up enough to literally knock stuff off walls and glasses off tables. As we suspected, everyone of the old farts at the bar left. The bar owner was pissed off.

But guess what? Little by little younger people started showing up but then leaving (we were ungodly loud so we must have drove them away too). But they kept coming back...and bringing more people with them. By the end of the night the bar was overflowing with people out into the parking lot and the bar owner told us afterward it was the best night he had in 30 years and wanted us back.

Moral of the story? Rock and Roll Ain't Noise pollution. Stop being such damn weenies and worrying about being so damned uptight and politically correct. Don't like how loud it is? There's the freakin' door ->!!! I'm finding more and more lately (as a vet rocker with a wife who bartends at a rock club), people are coming back to rock music and they are wanting it LOUD. And I'm not talking kids...I'm talking ALL age groups. It's about time too. I've just about had it with all this 'polite' karaoke level BS. Large loud bass rig making it hard on the soundman? We don't need no stinkin' sound man. We run it ourselves. If we had a soundman, he'd be working for us.

So is there a need for a huge rig? Obviously yes. If there wasn't, no one would make large cabs and big amps anymore. Dumb question really. Some want to go tiny, quiet or just DI. Good for you. Enjoy. That's cool you have the option today. Having to haul my own stuff to bar gigs, I'm digging lightweight gear. But it damn well better be able to get loud ONSTAGE. I play bass because I want to FEEL it. If all I wanted to do was hear it nicely, I'd be a guitard and play in a 'Bread' cover band.

I play in a classic hard rock band. I wouldn't want to offend anyone with loud rock music, now would I? ;) :D

To each his own.

+3dB
well said!
 
If you don't mind carrying the amp,
then no one else should tell you to get the newest lightweight fad,
ever.

You pay the bills, they don't. I can't STAND it when people bash someone else for having a 50 pound head or a 200 pound cab,
who cares? It's their rig, not yours.

I tend to play better when I can really feel and hear myself. Its just a confidence thing, I'm more confident because I can tell what's coming out of my bass better than just guessing, or god forbid, telling everyone I don't "need to hear it."

There are amps for a reason, use the big ones if you want.

+3dB
well said!
 
for instance, I am having a rough week. I posted about it earlies(and got some warm feelngs from the responses. Thank You. It got worse last night and then again this morning.
I would be thrilled and it would help me fell better if, I could play in a loud band with a huge amount of air (from bass speakers) blowing my hair and making the bell bottoms or elephant flare flap. This is difficult to obtain without cone area and power.
Typically I wuld prefer a much more reasonably sized amp& speaker set up.

Best of Luck,
Wesley R.
 
I'm not surprised the oldies like it loud too...

when my wife and I go to gigs with my parents-in-law (they're rockers too), it's ME that the one with the earplugs... they like it louder than me

I think it's because her parents' hearing must be even more damaged than mine is, so they need more volume just to hear anything at all

rock-induced hearing loss is maybe romantic as a purely abstract concept, but the reality of it is pretty far from desirable... I woke up one morning a few weeks ago with an awful ringing in my right ear, and was worried that this is it, the loud music's finally caught up, but it subsided & it must have been caused by something else... but when you face the prospect of permanent tinnitus.. it's not very rock'n'roll

anyway, I've wandered way off course... so to sum up... yes I have a large rig (oo-er missus) but I always wear uber-strength earplugs

I just had my hearing tested recently. I have very sharp hearing still at 48 years old after 30 years of gigging in rock bands (no earplugs).

BUT...I've always stayed on the hi-hat side of the drummer (away from crash cymbals and guitar stacks).
 
....... Is there really any need for huge rigs?

Ed

well......... I compete, quite literally, against THIS:

Link RemovedLink Removed
Portnoy_Kit_front.jpg
















so I use THIS:

Invalid Link RemovedLink RemovedInvalid Link RemovedInvalid Link Removed








soooooooooooo..........yes. Yes would be my answer
 
I've been playing in bands for 30 years, some loud, some quiet, playing at tiny bars ("there's room for the band over there, if you move the pool table") to large stages.

I remember a time long ago when rock music was meant to be played loud and with an attitude. From the stage as well as through the PA. I recall one gig where our agent sent us to some little dive country bar (back when Hank Williams SR was on the jukebox) out in a vast remote wasteland. Well, we brought in our whole outdoor PA (two double 18" scoops on each side, etc. etc. etc.) and I brought in the fridge with the SVT head. This was one of those "move the pool table to fit" bars.

We thought we'd stick it to our agent for sending us to musical Siberia by cranking our volume up enough to literally knock stuff off walls and glasses off tables. As we suspected, everyone of the old farts at the bar left. The bar owner was pissed off.

But guess what? Little by little younger people started showing up but then leaving (we were ungodly loud so we must have drove them away too). But they kept coming back...and bringing more people with them. By the end of the night the bar was overflowing with people out into the parking lot and the bar owner told us afterward it was the best night he had in 30 years and wanted us back.

Moral of the story? Rock and Roll Ain't Noise pollution. Stop being such damn weenies and worrying about being so damned uptight and politically correct. Don't like how loud it is? There's the freakin' door ->!!! I'm finding more and more lately (as a vet rocker with a wife who bartends at a rock club), people are coming back to rock music and they are wanting it LOUD. And I'm not talking kids...I'm talking ALL age groups. It's about time too. I've just about had it with all this 'polite' karaoke level BS. Large loud bass rig making it hard on the soundman? We don't need no stinkin' sound man. We run it ourselves. If we had a soundman, he'd be working for us.

So is there a need for a huge rig? Obviously yes. If there wasn't, no one would make large cabs and big amps anymore. Dumb question really. Some want to go tiny, quiet or just DI. Good for you. Enjoy. That's cool you have the option today. Having to haul my own stuff to bar gigs, I'm digging lightweight gear. But it damn well better be able to get loud ONSTAGE. I play bass because I want to FEEL it. If all I wanted to do was hear it nicely, I'd be a guitard and play in a 'Bread' cover band.

I play in a classic hard rock band. I wouldn't want to offend anyone with loud rock music, now would I? ;) :D

To each his own.

Good story. May I add, "there's room for your 10 piece band if you move that deuce/twotop/two people table". I play regularly in an upscale winebar/restaurant. The owner before our first gig told us we'd play in the wine room. Floor to ceiling wine bottles. I said, "What if we make them rattle?" He said, "Extra percussion". Who knew? The only time he told us to turn down he was smiling from ear to ear because he and the patrons were enjoying us so much. And one night he asked us to turn up!:eek:

This is about bass. As a salesman once said to me when you play outside you're trying to move all the air on the planet. You didn't think when we moved from the doghouse uprights that it would be easy on us did you. $%*& piccolo players.:) Not for ego but for feeling for me, my band and the audience do I take whats necessary. Whatever fills feels good. Front people like that cushion to lean back on too.
 
Sure they're not necessary, but how else are you going to make the panties moist?

Weight training, my friend! :smug:

The chicks aren't looking at your rig, their looking at the package and the pecs! :D


IMO, the big rig is obsolete in most cases. With sophisticated PA's and compact amp/cabs, huge rigs are becoming more and more scarce wit most mainstream bands. . YMMV. Hardcore and Heavy Metal are excluded, of course.
 
Sorry, this is a concept I just can't get my head around. If you're running an amp at 100w worth of its available power, what difference is there if you have an extra 200w or an extra 900w? You're still not going to go anywhere near clipping.

This may not make sence if you are going Direct in, but If you are driving any cabinet while doing so for anything but a monitor, headroom can be your friend.
 
I must just be an old fart as I don't understand the need for rigs like this guitar, bass or drums. I just come from a less is more place I guess.

This is subjective. How loud is loud? I don't play with guitarists using full or half stacks. As I said earlier, 15 watt boutique guitar amps can take your head off. I don't enjoy extremely loud music. Much of my inspiration comes from time I spend alone in the woods and I want to hear all of it. My groups have learned to blaze with intensity at volume where the first row of tables is talking to us and we can hear everything they say. We keep getting gigs because folks can hear smokin music without the detrimental effects. That being said I take a 1500 watt rig to many outside gigs. Yet mostly a 1000 watt rig does me fine. My wine bar rig is a 1000 watt 2x1x12 rig. There we play the volume of a sax player. That can be loud. It's about the music and how you fit. The fit is because you want to fit not by shear volume.
 
As far as were talkin about hign energy rock music, or anything that needs to be loud to get the point across, I must say I am too a true believer in pure horsepower on stage. Why send all those extra signals through the PA when you can just project the real, un mixed and un consolodated sound from your rig.

There better be a KILLER pa ( I mean big....) to accurately throw the kind of air that 2,3,or 4 full stacks might throw out on any given venue.

I feel like.... If the amp is there (or you as the player at least want it there) there is no reason to use the PA to try and re amplify the sound when it wasnt turned up in the first place.

I know most soundmen want to have all the authority over the sound, and I cant blame them too much; it is their house youre playin in. But I cant feel the same way necesarily about their gear, professionalism or abiliity to provide a good mix.

RIGS OF DOOM FOREVER!!!!!!
 
For me personaly, it's going to come down to how big the stage/venue is.

I can and have got away with a 2x10 on it's side for most shows, but on a big stage more would be better. Even with great p/a support and monitors, I'd prefer a little more oomph on big stages.

For those shows where it's appropriate, I'll go for a 2x15, of 8x10 or a 4x10 (pair of 2x10's). Got a decent size one coming up this weekend, and it's down to a 2x15 or a pair or 2x10's.
 
This may not make sence if you are going Direct in, but If you are driving any cabinet while doing so for anything but a monitor, headroom can be your friend.
That's not my point. My point is how much headroom do you need? The vast majority of people who run 1000+ watt rigs do so for bragging rights. There is no headroom benefit over a 500w amp when you're not turning up past 2 or 3 with either amp. Cliff Williams plays bass for AC/DC and he's never needed more than 600w.

Don't get me wrong...I think it's fine if you like saying you use a 1000w amp. But be honest about it...unless you're playing stadiums and arenas, it's all about saying, "I have 1000 watts!" ;)
 
I agree it is often unnecessary to mike everything. A nice balance of vocals through the PA with good amp volume is my fave. Well I'm the guy who said I'm using 1500 and or 1000 watts. These two amps actually sound really good to me and if they had 2 watts and sounded the same I'd have bought them. I don't need bragging rights. I've been playing too long for that. I long ago moved beyond the 8x10 etc. and often use a 30 watt 1x8 combo. I gigged three times a week for two years with a 160 watt BBII.
Headroom is your friend! I can play at a whisper to loud with only hand attack because of headroom. Dynamics are a huge part of music. Which is why these folks love the loud. They sometimes forget the soft and the spaces in between.