Okay, I should have this train wreck cleaned up soon. But before I start a new project and a new thread, I just wanna dump some random thoughts here, regarding design for a new build.
There's really not a single bass that I think is the perfect bass. But, there are a lot of individual elements and features that I like about a lot of different basses. I kinda struggle a little with copying designs. I don't mean making a complete copy of a bass, like a Ric (which I wanna do some day), etc. I mean making a one-off original, but stealing things from other designs. Don't get me wrong, I'll look at pics online and say, "ooh! I love the horns on that one, I'm doing mine like that!" But, then I change my mind because I feel like I should make my own. But, then I realize that everything has pretty much been done already, so even if wiped the slate clean and just sat with nothing but a pencil and paper and drew one completely out of my head,... There's no way it's not going to resemble something that's already out there, in some way.
I was looking at the S. Martyn Blaze headless the other day and admiring the body shape and horn shapes. Then I saw a Marleaux Diva and thought, what the heck! Which one came first? Because one totally copied the other. Or, is it the same maker?
Not being an instrument maker/model/history buff (before joining, I couldn't tell you the difference between a jazz and a P), I'm now finding out how many builders/manufacturers are out there, big and small, that are basically just copying other people's designs, making a few very minor changes and slapping their name on it.
Is this something that's just the norm and not thought of as a bad thing? Is it one of those, imitation is flattery kinda things? Does this bother people but everyone is just polite about it?
I mean, I knew that most large scale production builders have a rip-off version of a P bass with a very mild alteration to the headstock shape. And I was aware that that there's hobbyist level builders that build copies of their favorite basses. I didn't realize there was a middle ground of medium scale builders that are basically all copying each other's designs.
So, I guess what I'm getting at is, for me, when it's time to sit down and design my own bass,.... Should I just riff on other people's stuff that I like and just put my own little twist on it.... because it's acceptable? Or do I really just try to start fresh? I mean, it's a bass. It's going to resemble something, no matter what.
also, this isn't a real dilemma, because I'm not starting a business and making a product to sell. And I'm not judging anyone. This is just something I've been thinking about for when I try to seriously design something.
Is this something that anyone else thinks about? How do other people look at this and approach it?