• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Let's spread some musical misinformation

If the tuner was on while he played - big mistake! Everybody knows this reduces sustain by 82%. He should either turn the tuner off when he's playing or use a compression/sustain pedal, and while he's at it a little tube overdrive would also be an improvement.

The mandolin player and vocalist in that video is Lou Reid, and he's been playing music professionally for 45 years. He must be aware of this reduction in sustain from a tuner, and in fact may be relying on it for the sound he's trying to produce. He must also be aware of that near fatal bass guitar explosion that happened in 1990 or so. Oh, and the current bass player in the video? That's Christy Reid, his wife. I suspect he'll take the hit on his own playing to make sure his wife is safe.

All those fretted instruments, in perfect tune, played by such talented musicians, I'd say that if it wasn't for Lou Reid playing an out of tune note here and there they'd all be dead by now. He looks at the tuner every 15 seconds or so, likely keeping time on when the last off tune note was played. For a less talented band this would be unnecessary, as enough off tune notes would be played on accident to disperse the resonant energy built up. I think he saved that note as long as he could, he is a professional after all and takes pride in a well played song.
 
Oh, wow, I didn't know that. So, you've heard of this resonant effect too. This might also explain why cellos, violins, and basses have standardized sizes but violas do not. With variations in the string lengths among violas the chances of getting them in tune and hitting a resonance must go down.

I think the causation is the other way around. Since violas are played by viola players who can't play in tune, standardisation of size was and is seen as fairly pointless. They are just made a bit bigger than a violin so a viola player can at least recognise it. Even a viola player can compare things, more-or-less by size, and so will know not to try and put a cello under his or her chin 99% of the time.
 
I thought of this resonant effect and went back to this video because I thought something was odd but couldn't put my finger on it. If you look and listen real close to the video you'll see at 2:28 the mandolin player, with his electronic tuner on the head of the instrument, will glance at the tuner and hit a wrong note.



I've seen this band play before and that tuner can be seen every time they play the since they got a new bass player. Coincidence? I think not.


I played this and one of my dogs cried. She likes bluegrass as much as me.
 
Bluegrass originated when a colorblind hillbilly played the jug on his porch. Suddenly, Ol' Joe the Jug Player realized that the sky appeared the same shade as the grass, and the sky was always blue.

He barely had time to spit his tobacco juice out before yelling, "Blue grass!"

It stuck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikewalker
Bluegrass originated when a colorblind hillbilly played the jug on his porch. Suddenly, Ol' Joe the Jug Player realized that the sky appeared the same shade as the grass, and the sky was always blue.

He barely had time to spit his tobacco juice out before yelling, "Blue grass!"

It stuck.

Wait, I'm confused. What stuck? The name or the tobacco juice?
 
Bluegrass originated when a colorblind hillbilly played the jug on his porch. Suddenly, Ol' Joe the Jug Player realized that the sky appeared the same shade as the grass, and the sky was always blue.

He barely had time to spit his tobacco juice out before yelling, "Blue grass!"

It stuck.
He had fallen off the porch,and landed upside down. This happens every time he empties his jug, (just before playing you always have to empty your jug, at least I do!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shannon
No doubt you've paid your debt to society for these crimes..

Nomisinfo: Been busy, just getting back to this thread now.
Misinfo: Why, Yes, I've completely paid my debt and am no longer inflicting bad intonation (and timing and note choices and tone) on the public. With that said, I'll bow out Gracefully, in B flat.


A "Bass Bar" is a place where any upright citizens can quaff a pint or two; lawyers, however, must first sit a test and "pass the bar" before being allowed to belly up to the table.
 
Wait, I'm confused. What stuck? The name or the tobacco juice?

BOTH! So did the jug player, but that's not misinformation...

He had fallen off the porch,and landed upside down. This happens every time he empties his jug, (just before playing you always have to empty your jug, at least I do!)

Yup, although partial jugs can be used to add variety to your song. They also give you more to drink during it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bad azz tone
And the other 1% of the time? That's got to hurt getting an end pin in the Adam's apple.

It's why there is always demand for viola players.

I thought the violists were there to make the bassists look good.

Violinist: Do you like carrying around an instrument big enough to be your coffin?
Bassist: Well, at least I didn't jab myself in the throat with a cello like that guy over there.
Violinist: Touche.
 
BOTH! So did the jug player, but that's not misinformation...



Yup, although partial jugs can be used to add variety to your song. They also give you more to drink during it.
I thought the violists were there to make the bassists look good.

Violinist: Do you like carrying around an instrument big enough to be your coffin?
Bassist: Well, at least I didn't jab myself in the throat with a cello like that guy over there.
Violinist: Touche.
This is where modern body piercing all began.