Yup!
I have two P basses now that I have to work the Active/Passive switch back and forth, depending on what I'm going for.
One has a Dimarzio DP 122, a high output pickup. It can overdrive the front end when I dig in on the Passive setting.
The other has a 62 CS P pick up. It was fine until I switched string to La Bella 1954 flats 110-52. Those suckers drive that pickup into overdrive. Think James Jamerson isolated bass tracks. It's that sound!
So depending on if I want that sound or not, is what determines if I go passive or active.
![]()
Maybe someone can explain this to me; Hear is what I think I know
The Mesa Amps use typical Gain and Master Volume
lets say they are 0-10
Typically for Clean tone you set gain according to playing style and EQ used for OD light to just flash
when hitting hardest on E string[ slap/pop] when playing;
And it could be gain setting at 1 or 10 depending on Bass and EQ setting and then turn up Master Volume to needed level of output
So are you and Jack saying even with gain at 1 it is overloading input?
I have had basses fall between 4 and 6 mostly in my years playing with multiple Amps