• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Most obscure covers your band plays

The Ocean - not your typical Zep cover.
I was in a cover band a couple of years ago that did it, really fun. The singer couldn't do Plant so just dropped it an octave and did it bluesy, worked pretty well.

Maybe not too obscure for the genre, but little known by a lot of people:
Slaid Cleaves- Hard to Believe
Yeah pretty much anything by Slaid Cleaves is obscure, isn't it?

We do...

Vehicle-Ides of March
I played this in marching band in high school. It got a recent bump b/c of that American Idol dude was doing it. Great song.

Fearless by Pink Floyd - except we rock the S*** out of it !
We do this as a reggae tune, segued to from the Dead's "Crazy Fingers", also as a reggae groove, natch.

A few of our rare ones:
Escape - Rupert Holmes
Wait, isn't this the infamous "Pina Colada Song"?

I was in a band that did these


Deep Banana Blackout! I love Hope Claiborne, she used to be local around here.

So our most obscure cover is "Craven Choke Puppy" by the Wailers. We also do "Ghost Riders In The Sky" but we're covering the Willie Nelson & Johnny Cash version.

Marley's version:


One of my band's versions, this one is a bit fast:


Same show doing Ghost Riders:
 
No matter what - your goal is to entertain, not to say "look how cool and obscure I can get". I play in a band with a female singer that can hit Zep and Boston really well - so we pick out lesser known, but still known, songs, and the people love it.

You don't have to do "More than a Feeling" - any song on the album is remembered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HolmeBass
Why would a cover band play songs that no one really knows? Kind of defeats the purpose, does it not?

Most bands that do this are original bands who supplement the songs they write with obscure covers that they like, and more often that not these songs come off as an original song. A cover band wouldn't normally want to do this, as their crowd wants to hear songs they know and are comfortable with. I've always played my own music, so finding a rare gem and putting my own stamp on it has always been a lot of fun. I think someone else commented that an obscure cover defeated the purpose of a cover, same rule goes with that. If your a cover band musician, it wouldn't make sense. Two different schools of thought.
 
Most bands that do this are original bands who supplement the songs they write with obscure covers that they like, and more often that not these songs come off as an original song. A cover band wouldn't normally want to do this, as their crowd wants to hear songs they know and are comfortable with. I've always played my own music, so finding a rare gem and putting my own stamp on it has always been a lot of fun. I think someone else commented that an obscure cover defeated the purpose of a cover, same rule goes with that. If your a cover band musician, it wouldn't make sense. Two different schools of thought.

Makes sense, was thinking of top 40 cover bands doing songs no one knew.
 
How.can anyone expect to.play the.same.lame covers night after night and not throw up! The one off per set makes the popular swill doable. Especially if your band insists on note for note tedium. The ooccasional original, obscure, or personalized cover is all that stands between a good gig and a bloodletting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nixdad
My current band sticks to the radio hits so we tend to not play anything obscure. It keeps the cougars up & dancing! :whistle:

Once the lead singer of my previous band found out that I loved Porcupine Tree - as did he - he would throw me a bone and we'd do Shesmovedon every once in a while. It made the gigs tolerable since there was only so much Petty, CCR, the Stones, etc., I could take in one night.
 
I could go with two...Help Me Make It Through the Night by Freddy Fender (although many people know and associate it with the Kris Kristofferson version)

-OR-

Casualties by American Aquarium...This one is becoming less and less obscure though as more bands in our area are starting to play it. The dreaded byproduct of promoting band videos on Facebook.

 
We keep our stable of cover standards on tap to get the dance floor full, but we lean towards songs that the population recognizes, but doesn't hear often. ("Wow, that's a great song...haven't heard it played in a while!")
Probably the most obscure one we do though is The Dandy Warhols "Bohemian Like You"... Very catchy....vaguely recognizable....and dance-worthy.... NO ONE sits down when we insert it.
Cheerios!