• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Most underrated guitarist.

Got to echo some already mentioned:
Nels Cline
Jerry Reed
Roy Buchanan
Dean Ween
Eddie Hazel
Willie
Danny Gatton
Magic Sam
Adrian Belew
Glen Cambell

Also must add:
Steve Hillage
Tom Verlaine - Television
Peter Laughner - Pere Ubu
East bay Ray - DK
Phil Manzanera - Roxy Music
Eric Stewart & Lol Creme - 10cc
Lowell George
Uli Roth
I'm not much of a country guy, but after seeing your list, I've got to mention Buck Owens, who I had the privilege of meeting a few times and seeing several times at his Crystal Palace in Bako. And I never miss Merle's April homecoming shows. After all these years, he is still great. His son isn't bad either.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ELG60 and RHFusillo
Are "underrated" and "little-known" two different things?

The first name that came to mind was Sonny Landreth, but I'm not sure if he's one or the other or both.

I'll co-sign Lindsey Buckingham as "underrated."

And I'll a shout-out to Key West's own Caffeine Carl Wagoner, whom you don't know but wish you did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RHFusillo
A smooth cat from South Philly named Jimmy Marchiano(sp?) whose grandmother was one of my mother's best friends. Currently plays with a Zep tribute band called 'Get The Led Out' and could/should be rockin' stadium gigs. Of course, a Zep tribute needs 2-3 git-fiddlers but Jimmy has original stuff that could carry a power trio.

Whenever I hear "Top Jimmy" - I could almost believe EVH got the inspiration while seeing this kid playing out after a Philly show o_O
 
I always wonder where Alex Lifeson fits on these types of lists . . . To keep up with Geddy and Neil, you have to at least be good (unless they are carrying him . . .). Nonetheless, he is never mentioned on lists of great guitarists . . .

I was going to mention Lifeson too. He's one of my favourite guitarists. His solos always fit the song perfectly, but never come off as him showing off. I know he can play circles around a lot of other well-known guitarists but he never seems to get much love.

I do think that Geddy and Neil over shadow him though... In most rock bands, the guitarist steals the show. Whereas with Rush, each member contributes equally, which makes Geddy and Neil stand out more. If Alex were to join a traditional Blues band, I'd think his name would quickly be thrown in with the greats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rtav
My point exactly, no one knows who he is. If I started a thread with the title "Do you know who Al Di Meola is?" 75% would answer either no or carrots.

Yeah, but about a third of those voters would have voted carrots no matter what the question was... I never put carrots in my polls anymore. I'd rather someone not vote at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: birminghambass
I was a student of Linc Chamberland in the mid-70s.
Linc attracted students not just on guitar, but some bassists and other instruments. One of the few criticisms of my experience as Linc's student was that we would smoke pot during the lessons. Linc handled it fine, but I would turn into an idiot. He's been gone for about 30 years, and I think about him and what he taught me every day.

I studied with Linc for a year and a half. I probably wasn't good enough to smoke pot with him thank god. I remember a friend, Paul, who studied guitar with him complaining about that.
 
I have always felt that Larry LaLonde gets overlooked for his playing because Claypool stands out so much. He's the perfect compliment to Claypool with one tasty line after another.

Another guy I rarely hear anyone talk about is Trey Spruance from Mr.Bungle, a short stint with FNM, and Secret Chiefs 3. The guy can do it all.