• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

My quest to become as emo as possible.

'goths' in england are totally different from 'goths' over there i suspect :hmm:

anyway, 'goth' is far too big a generalisation.
i mean, if someone told me they were 'goth' i would go through this thought process-

1. they cannot be goth, for no goth would seriously call themselves a goth.

2. maybe they are being ironic, as is common in this wonderful subculture of ours.

3. if they are indeed goth, are they the cool glamour/sleaze goth? or the fat ugly victorian type.

4. is my makeup smudged?

5. i wonder where Joslin is.

meh, no 'goths' i know even call themselves goth anymore. they make up inventive genres such as Sleazy Space Queen and 80s Pillbox Coke Line Dillema :D
 
BrokenAngel said:
'goths' in england are totally different from 'goths' over there i suspect :hmm:

anyway, 'goth' is far too big a generalisation.
i mean, if someone told me they were 'goth' i would go through this thought process-

1. they cannot be goth, for no goth would seriously call themselves a goth.

2. maybe they are being ironic, as is common in this wonderful subculture of ours.

3. if they are indeed goth, are they the cool glamour/sleaze goth? or the fat ugly victorian type.

4. is my makeup smudged?

5. i wonder where Joslin is.

meh, no 'goths' i know even call themselves goth anymore. they make up inventive genres such as Sleazy Space Queen and 80s Pillbox Coke Line Dillema :D

Goths are pretty much the same all around, different brands of goth too. From Robert Smith to Robert Zombie.
 
BrokenAngel said:
'goths' in england are totally different from 'goths' over there i suspect :hmm:

anyway, 'goth' is far too big a generalisation.
i mean, if someone told me they were 'goth' i would go through this thought process-

1. they cannot be goth, for no goth would seriously call themselves a goth.

2. maybe they are being ironic, as is common in this wonderful subculture of ours.

3. if they are indeed goth, are they the cool glamour/sleaze goth? or the fat ugly victorian type.

4. is my makeup smudged?

5. i wonder where Joslin is.

meh, no 'goths' i know even call themselves goth anymore. they make up inventive genres such as Sleazy Space Queen and 80s Pillbox Coke Line Dillema :D



You’re so bright I have to wear shades just to read your posts.
… 4. is my makeup smudged?

5. i wonder where Joslin is.


What I have gotten out of this thread is the fact that dweebs now have their own genre.
 
Mr. Zebraface said:
See, this is why JR is one of my favourite TBers, he sticks up for emo, and has awesomeness music tastes! He is right, go listen to Bright Eyes and Sunny Day Real Estate and be educated, don't go slating bands just because you heard they were "emo." The MTV generation will ear-mark anything with melodies or guitars emo nowadays.

You and your little emo friends are being huge crybabies about this (gee, I'm surprised). The vast majority of people in this thread probably don't really care one way or the other about emo, we're just making fun of it because it's fun to do so. Chill out. :D
 
Emo, goth, gutter punk, glam kid, metal head, mod kid, hippie, greaser, swing kid... Young people have always had a need to categorize themselves in some way to feel that they "fit in". They are always alienated from the world, their parents, reality, etc. This is nothing new, and it will happen again, again, and again.

Categorizing oneself into a particular type of person is just plain lame.

I will have to say that of all the categories of types of people I've listed, emo is the only one that is associated with such terrible music. Even the best practitioners of emo, like Sunny Day Real Estate, are barely listenable. That stuff drives me up the walls.

Of course, as a gutter punk/goth/metalhead, I would say something like that.