• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD: BEST DECISION IN A LONG TIME!

(Still off-topic... sorry) +1 for the Ergo EUB! I have that same one in a five-string, also thinking of putting it up for sale, only because I don't play it enough. I've had mine maybe 10 years without a moment's trouble with it. I'm not sure the guy (Jesse Blue) is making them anymore, so they may be getting harder to find.
Me, too...wound up just using my upright--which I also plan on selling now; I've gotten too grumpy about schlepping it to gigs...and then using the gig money to pay the chiropractor...
 
How does the Decision compare to the Mercalli?

I have been on the fence for a Rev and can't try them out anywhere.

I didn't know of any place where I could try them out either; I just read tons of players' reviews, watched every video I could find...and then took the plunge: Fortunately, it worked out in both cases.

The Decision is extremely flexible, especially if you do pop gigs, due to the combination of P and J pickups--btw, I really like its slap tone.

I'm not 100% sure yet, but I'd probably be less inclined to use it where I needed a warmer tone--which would be where the Mercalli comes in.

My Mercalli is my go-to 5 string for country, rock, musical theater and jazz/ big band gigs when I need that B; I love it for everything except a gig where I need a bright slap tone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riff Ranger
I don't usually post about my bass purchases, but I LOVE THIS BASS!
Never had a PJ bass before;I'd been wanting one for quite a while....this one, to be exact...
And now, thanks to JxBass, I've got one...
After 5 shows this week, all played on the Decision, I can say with confidence that it's well on its way to being my new #1!
View attachment 4573990
Does Reverend make a short scale with a P/J setup?
 
There's so much tonal variety available, I don't know how much that would even improve it.
I played through several different brands and sizes of amps this week, and was totally happy with the sound I was able to get from the pickup combination and tone control...and I figure that it'll only get better as I use it more.
After years of mostly active basses, I've definitely headed in the opposite direction; to be honest, I found most preamps convenient to have onboard, but the treble in particular always bugged me out--sort of brittle.

(The one exception--among basses I've owned anyway--is the G&L preamp, which, once I learned not to dime either of the tone controls--much less the volume!-- gave me just what I wanted to hear.)

I wouldn't say I have a strong preference, but I do have a preference for active electronics in basses. I also am not averse to swapping pickups. I'm good with soldier and all that.

However, I have a Thundergun and Mercalli and I wouldn't muck with those pickups. They are outstanding in the sense that, whether full bridge or full neck, though you have a wide timbral change, the overall eq isn't messed up i.e. you don't have a massive loss of lows on the bridge, or too muddy a neck.
 
Very cool bass!
I am still surprised with that one , and it is hanging out with good friends too, definitely holds its own!
1AB8BAEC-43C2-48B9-BE84-2BA9B8B32570.jpeg