I tried the guitar version, the coating wears off the uncoated G,B & E strings pretty fast, significant coating wear off in less then a month from pick use. No such problem with the bass strings though even though I use same pick on bass. Bass strings havent shown any noticeable wear in 5 months. Maybe a tiny bit of wear that needs magnifying glass to see but thats it. Seems the coating doesnt do well on uncoated strings in my experience. BTW I really like the bass string version. sound, feel, and looks wise,
I have been using the coated (ELs, not the neon) acoustic strings for quite a while, and am familiar with how long they last. It seems to be a personal thing - my coatings almost never wear, but only if I'm the only one playing them. I once lent my acoustic to a good friend, a guitarist, and 15 minutes with him and a few chucks of the coating had flaked off.
Oh and in this tropical climate non-coateds are not an option, especially if you don't play that regularly. I've seen strings rust-out even in "corrosion proof" envelopes and plastic bags, not to mention attached to a guitar. I keep my unused strings in a dehumidifier.