• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Once again, Rush dissapoints

Well, the title of the thread alone should have been more of an indicator of the direction this would go. The only thing you can say with any assuredness with any band with a catalog as big as Rush has, is that most people in the audience will be unhappy with at least one song in the show. We really ought to just feel lucky that these guys are still around to entertain us...and do so playing as well as they ever have.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zontar
The worst thing about playing music for people is...the audience. :D
I think a band like Rush, a band I am only a small fan of, knows how to sell tickets just fine. All the set list naysayers won't make even a small dent in the pockets of Rush if they don't attend, which they will. Most of them anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zontar
This was the old-school Rush fan's DREAM. The show started with nearly all eras of the band represented from newest to oldest. The stage set changed between nearly every song with the backline changing accordingly. The first set wasn't so eventful, but after intermission...pure Rush PERFECTION. The entire stage was nothing but amps...behind Alex was 5 full Marshall stacks, and behind Geddy was a literal WALL of Ampegs; it is doubtful any of those amps were used, but they looked great. Slowly, after every song, some amps were removed gradually until at the end of the set the entire stage was bare (as a recreation of their first high school gig) except for Geddy's original Traynor amp (talk about attention to detail), 1 amp for Alex, and Neil's drum kit...which is a replica of the REAL Neil Peart's original 70's chrome Slingerland kit, double bass (!) with a full 4 piece array of open bottom concert toms! Neil Peart HATES nostalgia, so it was a HUGE surprise that he agreed to play his "old" setup that he discarded YEARS ago. Just seeing that drum kit brought tears to my eyes. The band's first set had Neil using his modern jazz based kit...but the REAL Peart (and most would say the REAL Rush) returned for the 2nd set, which represented Moving Pictures to the first album. Geddy used about a zillion basses, a bunch of Gibsons of all things, and broke out the old black 4003 for only "Red Barchetta" and it actually sounded a bit plunky and "hard to play;" it's doubtful that it was run in stereo as he hardly touched any of his Ricks and running a separate stereo setup would be too much of a hassle when he's already switching 20 basses in the set. When Geddy doesn't run his Rick stereo he uses them with both pickups full on without the cap which takes out most of that Rickenbacker midrange aggressiveness...and that's what it sounded like. It wasn't the Geddy Rick tone of old. Surprisingly, about the best SOUNDING bass through his modern setup that sounded the most like his OLD Rick sound was what looked like a late 50's Precision that he played on the horrid song "Roll the Bones." That Precision was a great growly midrangy honky bass that provided the most old-school Geddy tone, strangely enough. The band played a jawdropping set including the long-awaited "Jacob's Ladder," "Hemispheres/Prelude," "Cygnus X-1," "2112" including "Presentation" and "Grand Finale," and the ENTIRE "Xanadu" with full intro, real Moog, real percussion, and the return of both Alex's Gibson doubleneck AND Geddy's Rickenbacker doubleneck! Whodathunk that would EVER return!??!!!?!! Truly amazing! As if that wasn't enough, they even played "Lakeside Park," a song that Geddy has stated for ages that he HATES. I NEVER thought I would hear Rush play this song again, one of my absolute favorites! Then, they played "Anthem" too!!! Just mindblowing. Geddy's voice was in GREAT form, and he NAILED "Hemispheres" (tuned down of course, but WAY better than in 1994). They even played "What You're Doing" and part of "Garden Road" once it was all over...truly one of the BEST Rush shows I've EVER seen. Neil has lost some of his finesse and technicality a bit (he takes it a bit easy on the hard fills of old), and it might be difficult for Geddy to keep up throughout this tour hitting all those high notes in the second set. But, overall, it was WAAAAY better than I anticipated, with a PERFECT setlist for the 2nd half. Rush fans are in disbelief. If this IS the last tour, they FINALLY gave us old-school Rush fans EXACTLY what we've ALWAYS wanted. Absolutely unreal!


10881760_537588859715836_1013276451_n.jpg


11255652_632805916863787_411564557_n.jpg


11236399_611792905624735_1670529112_n.jpg


Invalid Link Removed

11235922_840186242729550_591946498_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
GGoat beat me to the report (and a great report it is!), but +1 to everything he said. The vast number of basses Geddy played was mind-blowing: a couple of Thunderbirds (white and 2TSB), a classic Les Paul, a Rick 4005, several different Jazzes (including green with a tort guard), and in Ggoat's last pic, what looks like a Silvertone of some sort. He could be heard, but the tone wasn't always great. Geddy sounded really good, vocal-wise. He couldn't hit some of the high notes, but overall he sounded much better than the last time I saw them. It was a fun concert from one the most talented bands out there, so how can anyone complain about that?

So, on to the set list. The leaked set list had some similarities, but not quite the same.
  1. Clockwork Angels
  2. The Anarchist
  3. Headlong Flight
  4. Far Cry
  5. The Main Monkey Business
  6. One Little Victory
  7. Animate
  8. Roll The Bones (the video during the rap is hilarious, with many celebrity cameos)
  9. Distant Early Warning
  10. Subdivisions
  11. Tom Sawyer
  12. Red Barchetta
  13. Spirit of the Radio
  14. Jacob's Ladder
  15. Cygnus X-1 Book II, then Book I (with drum solo)
  16. Closer to the Heart
  17. Xanadu
  18. 2112 (entire suite)
  19. Lakeside Park
  20. Anthem
  21. What You're Doing
  22. Working Man
 
This was the old-school Rush fan's DREAM. The show started with nearly all eras of the band represented from newest to oldest. The stage set changed between nearly every song with the backline changing accordingly. The first set wasn't so eventful, but after intermission...pure Rush PERFECTION. The entire stage was nothing but amps...behind Alex was 5 full Marshall stacks, and behind Geddy was a literal WALL of Ampegs; it is doubtful any of those amps were used, but they looked great. Slowly, after every song, some amps were removed gradually until at the end of the set the entire stage was bare (as a recreation of their first high school gig) except for Geddy's original Traynor amp (talk about attention to detail), 1 amp for Alex, and Neil's drum kit...which is a replica of the REAL Neil Peart's original 70's chrome Slingerland kit, double bass (!) with a full 4 piece array of open bottom concert toms! Neil Peart HATES nostalgia, so it was a HUGE surprise that he agreed to play his "old" setup that he discarded YEARS ago. Just seeing that drum kit brought tears to my eyes. The band's first set had Neil using his modern jazz based kit...but the REAL Peart (and most would say the REAL Rush) returned for the 2nd set, which represented Moving Pictures to the first album. Geddy used about a zillion basses, a bunch of Gibsons of all things, and broke out the old black 4003 for only "Red Barchetta" and it actually sounded a bit plunky and "hard to play;" it's doubtful that it was run in stereo as he hardly touched any of his Ricks and running a separate stereo setup would be too much of a hassle when he's already switching 20 basses in the set. When Geddy doesn't run his Rick stereo he uses them with both pickups full on without the cap which takes out most of that Rickenbacker midrange aggressiveness...and that's what it sounded like. It wasn't the Geddy Rick tone of old. Surprisingly, about the best SOUNDING bass through his modern setup that sounded the most like his OLD Rick sound was what looked like a late 50's Precision that he played on the horrid song "Roll the Bones." That Precision was a great growly midrangy honky bass that provided the most old-school Geddy tone, strangely enough. The band played a jawdropping set including the long-awaited "Jacob's Ladder," "Hemispheres/Prelude," "Cygnus X-1," "2112" including "Presentation" and "Grand Finale," and the ENTIRE "Xanadu" with full intro, real Moog, real percussion, and the return of both Alex's Gibson doubleneck AND Geddy's Rickenbacker doubleneck! Whodathunk that would EVER return!??!!!?!! Truly amazing! As if that wasn't enough, they even played "Lakeside Park," a song that Geddy has stated for ages that he HATES. I NEVER thought I would hear Rush play this song again, one of my absolute favorites! Then, they played "Anthem" too!!! Just mindblowing. Geddy's voice was in GREAT form, and he NAILED "Hemispheres" (tuned down of course, but WAY better than in 1994). They even played "What You're Doing" and part of "Garden Road" once it was all over...truly one of the BEST Rush shows I've EVER seen. Neil has lost some of his finesse and technicality a bit (he takes it a bit easy on the hard fills of old), and it might be difficult for Geddy to keep up throughout this tour hitting all those high notes in the second set. But, overall, it was WAAAAY better than I anticipated, with a PERFECT setlist for the 2nd half. Rush fans are in disbelief. If this IS the last tour, they FINALLY gave us old-school Rush fans EXACTLY what we've ALWAYS wanted. Absolutely unreal!


10881760_537588859715836_1013276451_n.jpg


11255652_632805916863787_411564557_n.jpg


11236399_611792905624735_1670529112_n.jpg


Invalid Link Removed

11235922_840186242729550_591946498_n.jpg

GGoat beat me to the report (and a great report it is!), but +1 to everything he said. The vast number of basses Geddy played was mind-blowing: a couple of Thunderbirds (white and 2TSB), a classic Les Paul, a Rick 4005, several different Jazzes (including green with a tort guard), and in Ggoat's last pic, what looks like a Silvertone of some sort. He could be heard, but the tone wasn't always great. Geddy sounded really good, vocal-wise. He couldn't hit some of the high notes, but overall he sounded much better than the last time I saw them. It was a fun concert from one the most talented bands out there, so how can anyone complain about that?

So, on to the set list. The leaked set list had some similarities, but not quite the same.
  1. Clockwork Angels
  2. The Anarchist
  3. Headlong Flight
  4. Far Cry
  5. The Main Monkey Business
  6. One Little Victory
  7. Animate
  8. Roll The Bones (the video during the rap is hilarious, with many celebrity cameos)
  9. Distant Early Warning
  10. Subdivisions
  11. Tom Sawyer
  12. Red Barchetta
  13. Spirit of the Radio
  14. Jacob's Ladder
  15. Cygnus X-1 Book II, then Book I (with drum solo)
  16. Closer to the Heart
  17. Xanadu
  18. 2112 (entire suite)
  19. Lakeside Park
  20. Anthem
  21. What You're Doing
  22. Working Man

Hardly sounds like a disappointing gig! Great reports. And that set list doesn't look like it's just rehashing standards, either. The proof is in the pudding - sorry I'll be missing this tour, but the Boston show is sold out.
 
TRUST RUSH!!!

I knew they wouldn't disappoint.
I guess Geddy couldn't resist breaking out some of his new collection, but that seems kinda odd. In a recent home studio interview he says he's trying to "recreate history with these basses".
A fireglow Ric doubleneck hmm.
A wall of ampegs!! Yesss.
Ooh I can't wait!!

Viva RUSH!!
 
This was the old-school Rush fan's DREAM. The show started with nearly all eras of the band represented from newest to oldest. The stage set changed between nearly every song with the backline changing accordingly. The first set wasn't so eventful, but after intermission...pure Rush PERFECTION. The entire stage was nothing but amps...behind Alex was 5 full Marshall stacks, and behind Geddy was a literal WALL of Ampegs; it is doubtful any of those amps were used, but they looked great. Slowly, after every song, some amps were removed gradually until at the end of the set the entire stage was bare (as a recreation of their first high school gig) except for Geddy's original Traynor amp (talk about attention to detail), 1 amp for Alex, and Neil's drum kit...which is a replica of the REAL Neil Peart's original 70's chrome Slingerland kit, double bass (!) with a full 4 piece array of open bottom concert toms! Neil Peart HATES nostalgia, so it was a HUGE surprise that he agreed to play his "old" setup that he discarded YEARS ago. Just seeing that drum kit brought tears to my eyes. The band's first set had Neil using his modern jazz based kit...but the REAL Peart (and most would say the REAL Rush) returned for the 2nd set, which represented Moving Pictures to the first album. Geddy used about a zillion basses, a bunch of Gibsons of all things, and broke out the old black 4003 for only "Red Barchetta" and it actually sounded a bit plunky and "hard to play;" it's doubtful that it was run in stereo as he hardly touched any of his Ricks and running a separate stereo setup would be too much of a hassle when he's already switching 20 basses in the set. When Geddy doesn't run his Rick stereo he uses them with both pickups full on without the cap which takes out most of that Rickenbacker midrange aggressiveness...and that's what it sounded like. It wasn't the Geddy Rick tone of old. Surprisingly, about the best SOUNDING bass through his modern setup that sounded the most like his OLD Rick sound was what looked like a late 50's Precision that he played on the horrid song "Roll the Bones." That Precision was a great growly midrangy honky bass that provided the most old-school Geddy tone, strangely enough. The band played a jawdropping set including the long-awaited "Jacob's Ladder," "Hemispheres/Prelude," "Cygnus X-1," "2112" including "Presentation" and "Grand Finale," and the ENTIRE "Xanadu" with full intro, real Moog, real percussion, and the return of both Alex's Gibson doubleneck AND Geddy's Rickenbacker doubleneck! Whodathunk that would EVER return!??!!!?!! Truly amazing! As if that wasn't enough, they even played "Lakeside Park," a song that Geddy has stated for ages that he HATES. I NEVER thought I would hear Rush play this song again, one of my absolute favorites! Then, they played "Anthem" too!!! Just mindblowing. Geddy's voice was in GREAT form, and he NAILED "Hemispheres" (tuned down of course, but WAY better than in 1994). They even played "What You're Doing" and part of "Garden Road" once it was all over...truly one of the BEST Rush shows I've EVER seen. Neil has lost some of his finesse and technicality a bit (he takes it a bit easy on the hard fills of old), and it might be difficult for Geddy to keep up throughout this tour hitting all those high notes in the second set. But, overall, it was WAAAAY better than I anticipated, with a PERFECT setlist for the 2nd half. Rush fans are in disbelief. If this IS the last tour, they FINALLY gave us old-school Rush fans EXACTLY what we've ALWAYS wanted. Absolutely unreal!


10881760_537588859715836_1013276451_n.jpg


11255652_632805916863787_411564557_n.jpg


11236399_611792905624735_1670529112_n.jpg


Invalid Link Removed

11235922_840186242729550_591946498_n.jpg

Best Post Ever.
 
OP here. Since I got so much flak for having an opinion, I felt it necessary to update my thoughts after the first show.

Well..........

I'm not ready to "eat my words" since I still think that the setlist sucks for the most part. But I would like to say that the stage show itself is amazing and seeing Peart play those double kick drums again almost brought a tear to my eye. It's funny though, 10 years ago I was a regular member of Rushisaband and brought up two things that would make a Rush show great......Geddy Lee playing his analog moogs again and Peart ditching the single kick set. Well, much like here, I got the million fanboy's negativity of "Hey, it's Rush, they can do what they want," and "who the hell are you to say what the boys shouls do."

Well, now that these two things have come true (although Geddy's been rockin the moogs since 08), I notice these same fanboy's stumbling all over themselves to say how awesome it is.

That's the thing about Rush fans that really bugs me. Nobody is allowed to critique, criticize or in any way shatter the illusion of integrity. But then they do a complete 180 when it is convenient.

Anyway, just a quick half mea culpa here. I still wouldn't pay the money they are asking, but I am very happy to watch videos online of my favorite band rocking the instruments they are.
 
It's funny though, 10 years ago I was a regular member of Rushisaband and brought up two things that would make a Rush show great......Geddy Lee playing his analog moogs again and Peart ditching the single kick set. Well, much like here, I got the million fanboy's negativity of "Hey, it's Rush, they can do what they want," and "who the hell are you to say what the boys shouls do."

Well, now that these two things have come true (although Geddy's been rockin the moogs since 08), I notice these same fanboy's stumbling all over themselves to say how awesome it is.

That's the thing about Rush fans that really bugs me. Nobody is allowed to critique, criticize or in any way shatter the illusion of integrity. But then they do a complete 180 when it is convenient.

I don't see it. You describe people saying "enjoy what is offered", followed by them enjoying what is offered, which is the correct way to experience the arts.