• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Owning both a P Bass and a Jazz

View attachment 3323493 I sold actual Fender P and J basses recently,and replaced them with these 2.
very impressive! I hope to have some flats on my L2KT today (if it stops raining) so I can (please!) get a classic thumpin combo like you have there into 1 vintage groove monster.
upload_2019-2-15_7-45-27.png
 
I sat in when a friend (drummer) asked me to join him and some friends for an open mic jam.
After my turn to play another bass player approached me (remember...just an open mic thing) and said, "you have no pedals, how do you get your sound".
Not being 100% clear on what he was asking I said, "I only need 2 sounds".
He asked what they were...i replied, "good and better".
He walked away.
 
I currently own a Precision and a Jazz and love both. I might prefer one for some things and the other for other things, but they both fit into any of my playing situations. Nice to have choices.

For that matter, I also have a Stingray 5 and an L-2500, which are also part of Leo Fender's legacy. All different but all great basses.
 
I have an 80's (I think) no-name P copy with some decent pickups in it and an American Standard Jazz that replaced a highway 1 jazz. I tend to favor jazz basses for whatever reason but record with both. I would like to add an a player P to the mix soon.
 
To the OP,

I think those are two great basses. I would be interested in trying a Players Series bass. While they might not have all of the appointments of a MIA bass, P's and J's are so adjustable that I bet you can dial them in great.

Enjoy!
Bones
 
I find the difference in Ps and Js to be quite useful. Just yesterday I was tracking the bass part on a tune in the studio. After using my P bass for most of the songs on the album this one song was just not working as well with the P. I was finding it hard to get the note definition I needed. The part has a busy bass line of constant 8th notes. So I switched to the J (with tape wounds). In this case it was the right bass sound for the song.
 
Owning both is very common. I had both and eventually found that I could get close enough to a P bass sound from my J bass. So now I have a J bass (Nash JB-63) and a Stingray Special 5. Happy! But a P would be nice some of the time.