• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Owning both a P Bass and a Jazz

I have the wonderful predicament of loving them all so much that I have a hard time choosing which to take to the gig.
I have that issue too. It honestly has kept me from pulling the trigger on a new one more than once. Not sure I need to agonize over yet another great bass to take out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: quilanthegreat
A very strong argument can be made that both of those are also actual Fender basses. I love my G&L's.
Agreed! I've owned Fenders intermittently over the years,and really liked the 2 late model ones i had very well,but sold/treaded them.
Having said that, I am loving these 2 GL's. The lb100 is a '17 model. I don't know when the jb2 was made,but it seems to be made to the same high quality standard as the lb100.
 
IMG_7920.JPG


I'm good with owning both! I play with two different groups. One is a small piano/bass/drums trio and the Jazz brings a lot of personality to that. The other is a larger band with guitar, keys, and brass, and the P sits just right in that mix.
 
I've got a 77 Precision and a mid-80s MiJ Jazz Bass Special (which is a P/J with a P body). Funny story is that in the mid 80s I was looking for a fretless J, spent a weekend in Chicago looking and the best I could come up with was the Special. It was my main bass for many years. But I still GAS for a classic J to match my classic P. Have considered just grabbing an MiM J; my MiM telecaster is pretty damn nice, actually. But then I wonder how much I'd even play it. My tribby L-2500 gets all my love when I'm playing BG these days. It does everything.
 
I'd guess that's pretty common. I have a 4 string passive "J" bass and an active "modern" 5 string. I don't play the 4 string often. It's an ok bass but not like my 5. I sometimes think I'd like a passive 4 string P but as I seem to only play my active 5 it's hard to justify.
 
Haha, I kind of felt like I replaced a P and J both with an L2500 - in passive mode, it definitely gets P like, a little further from J territory.
G&L makes a nice bass. Active 5 or passive 4. I find that for now, for me live, if I roll off the treble, roll to the neck pup and watch my playing style, my Roscoe gets a convincing P bass sound. Likewise, the bridge pup with a little bass boost gets me a nice barky J tone.
 
I thought at one point I could pull off both sounds with a P/J. When you really want the exact tone, that just doesn't work, apparently. Got rid of that, now I've got two Fender P's (both MIM, a Standard and a Player) but have never owned a Fender J. I hope to get one as my next bass. I love that yours match!
Yah, I tried to achieve that with an L2500. Amazing basses that can get close, but never exactly there on both counts, P or J....
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGeekJack
View attachment 3323493 I sold actual Fender P and J basses recently,and replaced them with these 2.

Our paths cross again :D
I have these three G&L's, a Squier VM 70's Jazz with Dimarzio Area P's and the Franken PJ with EMG Geezers in it. I have more I can dig out but it doesn't matter. I'm selling all except the G&L's in this picture. The LB-100 (P-Bass) is what I ALWAYS go back to. It is an absolutely INCREDIBLE instrument!

G&L's.jpg
 
Last edited:
Our paths cross again :D
I have these three G&L's, a Squier VM 70's Jazz with Dimarzio Area P's and the Franken PJ with EMG Geezers in it. I have a more I can dig out but it doesn't matter. I'm selling all except the G&L's in this picture. The LB-100 (P-Bass) is what I ALWAYS go back to. It is an absolutely INCREDIBLE instrument!

View attachment 3323776
Love that tobacco burst in the middle!
It's what i had hoped my used jb2 was going to be,but i was fooled by the typically bad GC online photo. I'm still extremely pleased with the bass,though!