• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

P bass flats?

I was thinking about putting some flats on my p bass, and was wondering if I could still get a good rock sound out of it. Not necessarily a hard rock or metal sound but more like a Zeppelin type of a deal. a while ago i swapped the pups out for Fender original p bass pups and those are great. at least I know i'll be all over an old chool thumpy bit if i switch to flats:smug:

any thoughts?
 
I use Fender 9050ML's on my 62RI P-Bass and Tony Franklin Fretless P. I'm very pleased with the classic P tone I get on the fretted and can get close to an upright bass tone on the fretless. These gauges also give a pretty consistent tone string-to-string. They're not too expensive either.

LaBella Deep Talkin Flats are also spoken well of around here. I haven't tried them but from what I've read the tone is similar to that of the Fenders.

John
 
They'll be perfect for Zeppelin, although I gather JPJ played rounds by that point in his career.

In spite of what JPJ said in an interview last year, saying that he stopped using flats after his session days, he was using flats on his jazz bass in zeppelin. I have a Guitar Player interview from 1977 where he is very clear on this point, stating that he used Rotosound flats. The photographic and video evidence would seem to back this as well.

He also contrasted them with what he used on his Alembic (which was fairly new to him at the time), and the old single coil precision (or tele) bass he used, stating that he used Rotosound rounds on both of those because "they demanded that one use a brighter string", or something along those lines.
 
I can give another thumbs up for the TI flats - I've got them on my Pino Custom shop P and really like them. However, if you want to spend a little bit less and get, IMO, a little more thump, go with LaBella Deep Talkin' Flats. Both work well in a rock setting.

I just starting using these (.45 - .105) on one of my P's and am extremely pleased with them. So much so, that I plan on replacing the TI's on my Jazz with Labella's. Heck, maybe you can afford TI's... 8-month old TI's. :smug:
 
I really dig flats in the right setting. But for me, Zeppelin like rock-n-roll sounds a lot more defined and punchy with a good set of nickel rounds.

But if on a budget and you want Labella 760FLs, this is the best price I know of:

Link Removed
 
I use Fender 9050ML's on my 62RI P-Bass and Tony Franklin Fretless P. I'm very pleased with the classic P tone I get on the fretted and can get close to an upright bass tone on the fretless. These gauges also give a pretty consistent tone string-to-string. They're not too expensive either.

LaBella Deep Talkin Flats are also spoken well of around here. I haven't tried them but from what I've read the tone is similar to that of the Fenders.

John

I also recommend 9050ML's. They sound great on P-Basses.

Another 9050ML fan here.

Josh

They're inexpensive and sound pretty good, i've had a set on a bass for over 6 months and it sounds fine
 
I'm a huge TI fan. I love the flats on my SB1, and the SA's on my L2K. They last forever. The current set of flats have been on for a year and a half. The SA's have been on my L2K for over 8 months.

My SB2 is currently sporting DA Chromes. Great alternative to the TI's.... and much cheaper. Give them a shot.

Ljazz
 
Years ago when I was doing a blues/rock thing, I strung my P w/TI flats and OMG.... the tone was HUGE. Had that full, Muscle Shoals kinda tone to it... almost a fretless quality. Would make for a good classic rock tone imho.

The TI's are a li'l pricey, but so are Elixirs.. and like Elixirs they're worth the money cuz they sound good & last for a dog's age.
 
I have a set on my '62 Jazz bass reissue, and a set on my '62 P-bass reissue. These were around 20 bucks at Guitar Sphincter. A GREAT price for this set. The TI''s are truly great strings, but only IF you like light tension flats. I also love the LaBella flats, they are kind of in between the TI's and Fenders as far as price- about 38 bucks, and initial brightness goes. In my opinion, the Fenders are equal to the LaBellas I love so much, but are far easier to find, and are less expensive, both big factors in string preference. I have a set of Rotosound Jazz bass flats on my Warmoth '50's style maple neck Precision, and these are killer sounding, bright, punchy strings. The gauges are 110, 95,70,55, I believe...and the drawback to them is that they are very high tension, too high for many players. I play upright, and it is not a real issue for me. They come in lighter gauge sets, they might be just what your looking for. The new, out of the package tone is quite unlike most flats, it is very roundwound-like. They still retain the punch of a flat, however, and as they break in, the tone gets better. My all-round pick as the best string if all the factors are considered, are the Fenders, no contest.
 
Flats are good for a long time. You find new-ish sets of them for sale in classifieds on a regular basis... especially sets like the TI's that are fairly pricey to begin with. TI's are not for everyone -- this gives you a chance to try them at half the price.
 
I just put the Labella FL's on my MIM P. Sound good - little bit higher tension than that stock Rounds. I think I am gong to upgrade the pickups next - Bass sounds better unamplified and the pups are not bringing that great tone forward.

Playing wise - I like these flats a lot - but they are my first set - so I can't compare them to anything at this point except the stock rounds. 43 - 104 is the Gauge and I still need to play the slight brightness off them. But fast and a nice feel overall.

They are called lights - but they play very similar to the Med 45-105 set I had on previously - slightly more tension.

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]
 
alright everyone sorry to dig up a super old thread but I just wanted to say that I put labella deep talkin' nylon tapewounds on the p bass and it sounds super nice. I don't get the grind like I used to with rounds but man does it cut through now.
thanks everyone!