• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

P, J or Other? What do you usually play?

What is your main sound?

  • P-style bass

    Votes: 143 32.9%
  • J-style bass

    Votes: 106 24.4%
  • Other (Stingray, Ric, dual HB, etc).

    Votes: 186 42.8%

  • Total voters
    435
487996_main_l_201611141331.jpg


I voted other. Looks like a P/J but it’s actually a P/H.
 
Because I know @jd56hawk will post his, here's my 1989 G&L L-2000 (ha, beat you!). Most powerful bass I've ever owned. Wonderfully made. Plays and sounds like a champ. Two of Leo's finest Magnetic Field Design pickups in this baby.

She is 29 years old in April! Looks good for her age...View attachment 2862319
That looks great. I think the black powder-coated bridges add a lot to the look.

Just to be contrary I'll post this one.
I've been using it a lot the past few weeks fooling around with a jazz bass line I wrote.
2cp81fn.jpg
 
Been gigging lately with my L2500, but missing my Ps. I have 2 PJ-4s, a P4 and just bought a P5. It might be psychological, and I probably couldn't tell the difference in a blind test, but I TRUST that a Precision is delivering the sound I want when I'm on stage.

I voted P! :D
 
I own several basses including MIA Fenders, Spector, Alembic and a few others. My main bass is an MIA Jazz but I also play an MIA Precision for some songs and a Spector 5 string Neck Thru.
 
P and Ray do all the work for me.
I voted P because it's used with a band that gets most of the live gigs work.

I use my ray more for recording, and with 2 other bands but I gig less with those 2 bands. Also, my P is half a step down while my Ray is in standard tuning, so ray gets more "jam at my computer" work as well.
 
My favorite without question is a good ole P-Bass. My Clement is a PJ setup, and when playing that it's usually on the P pickup and passive. BUT... It's a 4 string. For that reason and pretty much only that reason, I play my Roscoe Century 6 like 60-70% of the time. It's set up with the spacing and aperture of jazz pickups, but it functions like a modern 6. The tone is in the same neighborhood as a jazz (but better, because usually I don't get along with a jazz) so I voted jazz.

But as soon as I pick up a P5 of some sort, my vote will most definitely change.
 
I currently own a PJ, a P, and an MM.

I like the action on my MM the best, but it pales in comparison to the sound of the P. With my rig (Mesa Boogie Subway D-800 into two vertically stacked GK 2x10 cabs) the MM sounds woofy, and it's difficult to hear myself on stage....even with the speakers stacked vertically). With the P, the notes just jump out.

IMO for the music I play (classic rock) the P just sounds better.
 
I play covers. So, I mainly need instruments that can cover all the traditional sounds. Here are a couple of them.
F66FEBF7-CEB0-4629-A7DE-81ED07D082BE.jpeg

7791E616-27F5-4DB2-8BB9-71C92D155BBE.jpeg

C080E650-1B0A-400A-8B3D-C78C6DDBB421.jpeg


I dig a great P. But, nowadays there are pickups and preamps available that can pretty well cop the P tone. Since I only take one bass to each gig, I tend to go with instruments that can cover several different vibes.
 

Latest posts