I want fairly heavy coloration for today's (over)processed radio metal -- Seether, Nickelback, etc. I picked up the Vintage Deluxe for retro OD tones. Overall, I agree with you, duke: for "always on" light OD, I would just boost the Gain on the 1200 and dig in for the dirt.
Pickstyle is indeed great for that.
~~~~~ off-topic pedal content ~~~~~
Never tried the XD1, but I really like the XD2. I don't gig it much because it's complicated (11 knobs?), and between levels, EQ, and crossover point, getting just the right shade of OD can be a tricky balancing act. (This is my fault: I just have to get more familiar with the pedal). I generally prefer OD pedals that have a mix/blend knob: without that they do tend to suck lows. The XD pedal does have ways of restoring those lows, especially if you go for clean lows, dirty mids/treble.
The Team Awesome Fuzz Machine that Ukiah mentioned sounds pretty darn cool on YouTube, I wasn't aware of that one. I've already busted my 2015 gear budget, though.
~~~~~ off-topic pedal content ~~~~~
Never tried the XD1, but I really like the XD2. I don't gig it much because it's complicated (11 knobs?), and between levels, EQ, and crossover point, getting just the right shade of OD can be a tricky balancing act. (This is my fault: I just have to get more familiar with the pedal). I generally prefer OD pedals that have a mix/blend knob: without that they do tend to suck lows. The XD pedal does have ways of restoring those lows, especially if you go for clean lows, dirty mids/treble.
The Team Awesome Fuzz Machine that Ukiah mentioned sounds pretty darn cool on YouTube, I wasn't aware of that one. I've already busted my 2015 gear budget, though.