• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Roscoe Club

Im in a conundrum and would like to know our collective opinion on Ash vs Mahogany?

IMO, they are both good on a Roscoe, but I prefer the tone of ash for fretted and the tone of mahogany for fretless. I've had a Roscoe ash fretless, and didn't dig it as much. Can't remember if I owned a Roscoe mahogany fretted, but I've had other fretted mahogany instruments that have come and gone. The mahogany mids work really well on a fretless to me.
 
IMO, they are both good on a Roscoe, but I prefer the tone of ash for fretted and the tone of mahogany for fretless. I've had a Roscoe ash fretless, and didn't dig it as much. Can't remember if I owned a Roscoe mahogany fretted, but I've had other fretted mahogany instruments that have come and gone. The mahogany mids work really well on a fretless to me.
Depends on the sound someone wants. It's a very personal thing. I've played mahogany body fretted basses for many years. Very even and a bit darker. Mahogany with an ebony board is a favorite combo of mine. Lighter ash is slightly scooped, which gives it a nice snap. Med to heavy ash has more weight in the sound as well...has a tighter bottom and a bit more going on in the mids.
 
Depends on the sound someone wants. It's a very personal thing. I've played mahogany body fretted basses for many years. Very even and a bit darker. Mahogany with an ebony board is a favorite combo of mine. Lighter ash is slightly scooped, which gives it a nice snap. Med to heavy ash has more weight in the sound as well...has a tighter bottom and a bit more going on in the mids.

I fully agree. For the genres I personally perform/record, medium-light (8-9.5 lbs) ash is my tone I like, and medium-heavier (9-10.5 lbs) mahogany is the fretless tone I've found I like. Moreover, that is just talking Roscoes, doing the things I do on Roscoes, etc. YMMV because my ears are attached to my goofy head. Tone preferences are super personal.
 
I fully agree. For the genres I personally perform/record, medium-light (8-9.5 lbs) ash is my tone I like, and medium-heavier (9-10.5 lbs) mahogany is the fretless tone I've found I like. Moreover, that is just talking Roscoes, doing the things I do on Roscoes, etc. YMMV because my ears are attached to my goofy head. Tone preferences are super personal.

Well Adam I totally love your playing and the sounds you get with your Roscoe’s so I think we are hearing very similar stuff. :)
 
Just window shopping on FretSpot and noticed the Century Signature doesn’t have the Mother Of Pearl for “R” logo nor for the thingy at the 12th fret.

What’s the deal? Over.

From time to time Keith ran out of abalone (and mother of pearl) and a few signatures received capped rear of the headstocks instead. It was usually done with the players consent though. Personally though, the wedge neck and the abalone (or mother of pearl) were the two features that I loved the most on a signature.
 
. . noticed the Signature doesn’t have mother-of-pearl “R” logo or 12th fret fingerboard marker. .
. . wedge neck and abalone were 2 Signature features that I loved most. .

Watched Donovan's video to learn that he asked KR (wise man that Donovan) to spec and choose features. So, configuration and features were the master artisan's choice, reflective of his signature, just as was standard in build-practice past at the Roscoe shop. Check the video starting around 1min, 14secs for reference.


https://www.fretspot.com/in-stock-now/roscoe-century-signature-5-koa-birdseye-maple-wenge-ash-more/
 
Last edited:
I’ll hold out until I can get this one in a Signature.
View attachment 4639321
I just bought that bass! It's amazing. I couldn't tell you what other basses it sounds like - most likely another Roscoe. In my opinion it does everything a person could want it to sound wise and playability.

Edit: I'd talk trade for only this bass

View attachment 4641846

Hopefully this fixed the link
 
Last edited:
I just bought that bass! It's amazing. I couldn't tell you what other basses it sounds like - most likely another Roscoe. In my opinion it does everything a person could want it to sound wise and playability.

Edit: I'd talk trade for only this bass
It certainly looks amazing, too! :woot:
The link to the bass you seek is broken. I’m certain I don’t have it, but would like to see it. :)
 
Last edited:
Roscoe Body.JPG


How's this?
It certainly looks amazing, too! :woot:

Yes it does! Thanks!
 

Attachments

  • Roscoe Body.JPG
    Roscoe Body.JPG
    810.8 KB · Views: 56

Latest posts