• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

RULES YOU'D LIKE TO SEE ON TB

More of an option really, something to minimize some of the redundancy. A "close/delete" option on all threads similar to polls where after a certain number of people vote for it's close or deletion a note gets sent to the appropriate mod who then closes or deletes it if they deem appropriate. The only problem would be the emergence of countless "what happened to my thread?" threads.
 
I'd like to see a rule that requires proof of endorsing artist status or a working relationship with a manufacturer in the disclosure statement.

This would probably be too time consuming and difficult to enforce, but I'm not convinced that all claims of these relationships are legitimate.
 
maybe adding an \[adult] \[/adult] tag? (escaped so you can see them Any other way to escape the \[ and \] characters in vBulletin?)

Unregistered/not-logged-in viewers or logged-in minors see a "---censured---" line.
Of those logged in, only those older than 21 can see the content.

Not really useful and might do more harm than anything else, but I was thinking about it the other day, so I mention it. I wouldn't implement it.
 
More of an option really, something to minimize some of the redundancy. A "close/delete" option on all threads similar to polls where after a certain number of people vote for it's close or deletion a note gets sent to the appropriate mod who then closes or deletes it if they deem appropriate. The only problem would be the emergence of countless "what happened to my thread?" threads.

That's what the report button is for, no?
 
In all honesty I think the rules here are fine. I think the old timers whine too much about recurring threads. It's a large internet forum with a pretty big turn around, not everyone has been here for years and seen it all. There's always new opinions and views from new members or even old who might have something different to say.

If recurring threads REALLY bother you that much, maybe you should spend less time on TB after all these years, or make the place more interesting yourself. Or better yet, just don't open those threads only to whine about them.

If someone starts a pretty common thread, and is told to use the search button, a lot of those threads in the search are full of the same posts telling you to search for another older thread and don't have much info in them.
 
Although I abide by the rules the best I can, I would like to see LESS of them. And I think that the only reason there ARE so many rules is that people are weak and get offended too easily. I, for one, LOVE a good discussion with someone who sees things differently than I do. I love to debate (calmly) religion and politics as well. I don't think my way is the only way. And I don't think you are stupid if you dissagree with me. If more people were like this, things could be more wide open around here. But all that being said, I like the forum and do my best to follow the rules. And when I have screwed up a few times, I jump at the chance to make it right once it's been pointed out to me.
 
Although I abide by the rules the best I can, I would like to see LESS of them. And I think that the only reason there ARE so many rules is that people are weak and get offended too easily. I, for one, LOVE a good discussion with someone who sees things differently than I do. I love to debate (calmly) religion and politics as well. I don't think my way is the only way. And I don't think you are stupid if you dissagree with me. If more people were like this, things could be more wide open around here. But all that being said, I like the forum and do my best to follow the rules. And when I have screwed up a few times, I jump at the chance to make it right once it's been pointed out to me.

+1
 
Although I abide by the rules the best I can, I would like to see LESS of them. And I think that the only reason there ARE so many rules is that people are weak and get offended too easily. I, for one, LOVE a good discussion with someone who sees things differently than I do. I love to debate (calmly) religion and politics as well. I don't think my way is the only way. And I don't think you are stupid if you dissagree with me. If more people were like this, things could be more wide open around here. But all that being said, I like the forum and do my best to follow the rules. And when I have screwed up a few times, I jump at the chance to make it right once it's been pointed out to me.

I disagree with you and think you're stupid.
 
No more "girl / guy issues" threads.

No more SX megathreads.

Madatory search before posting of redundant threads

No more "counrty of origin" bashing threads

No more "why do you need more than 4 strings" threads

No more vagues thread titles or badly executed innuendo laced titles.

No more "hey, does this neck fit my squier?" threads in Luthier Forum. I mean really. pick up a damn ruler and check for yourself. Not to mention it's not a luthier issue.

Aww, c'mon. 'Dear TB love advice' threads are always the best
threads. The Nebraska Husker Hottie thread failed so hard
that it was Mt. Rushmore with a Facepalm. Epic.