I personally doubt I could tell you if I was playing a rosewood or maple fretboard blindfolded. I've had basses with both, and they've sounded near enough identical after my pedals, amp and cab have come into play. I love the look of a dark rosewood, ebony, even a highly figured pau ferro in other people's pictures, too. I even have a Jazzmaster with a rosewood board.
For some reason though, when it comes to bass, I have like an 80/20 preference to maple boards. That alone will be a deciding factor choosing between instruments - I love the sherwood green Mustang PJ, but I don't know if I'd buy it over the butterscotch blonde, simply because of the pau ferro board vs the blonde's maple. Never used to be this way, I got no idea why it's become a thing for me.
For some reason though, when it comes to bass, I have like an 80/20 preference to maple boards. That alone will be a deciding factor choosing between instruments - I love the sherwood green Mustang PJ, but I don't know if I'd buy it over the butterscotch blonde, simply because of the pau ferro board vs the blonde's maple. Never used to be this way, I got no idea why it's become a thing for me.