• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Sell me on a 5 string.

Custom Maruszczyk:

Invalid Link Removed

~$1600 for something like this, have a play with the options :)

Screenshot_20181222-123245~2.png
 
I would look for 35"scale basses they usually have a much better B string as far as clarity and sustain . Yes you can get a decent B string on a 34 scale but IMHO it is hit or miss.

I’d suggest that the fault of floppy B strings is a tension issue, and that the string manufacturers are where the fix should have been made. A 35 inch scale wouldn’t have been necessary if the string makers had started with big enough B strings, where the tension was in line with the rest of the set.
 
Schecter is a great 5. I have 2. They (most) have a slim but flat neck profile and are a good value for the money. The scale is 35”, but honestly my Elite 5 is shorter than my Jag 5 that is a 34” Scale. I have no affiliation with this bass or the seller, am posting this link as an example:
Schecter Raiden Special 5 Bass | Evolution Music

If you come across one of these in a pawn shop or music store, would be a great intro to what Schecter 5s are about for minimal cash. - oh and they are very light. My elite is 8.5 lbs.
 
I'd find a bass you can play with ease, one that feels just right, then make it sound how you want.

A Sire upgraded with a Geezer EMG system might work, and at less than half your budget.
 
If this is your first 5, then research is needed before brand suggestions are valid. 5's come in a variety of scales with different string spacing, nut widths and neck profiles. Finding the one that fits you is a large part of the process and a huge factor in a successful transition. As a long time 5-string-only player, I went through all of it, from 34"-35" scale and 16.5mm-19mm spacings and eventually found what worked for me: a Wilkins 34" PJ5 with 18mm spacing. I had a closet full of 35"/19mm at one point and they worked for a while until I picked up the bass I have now, and instantly knew that was 'the one' for me and it has been for years.

If you can, go to a bass store and play every 5 string you can get your hands, regardless of brand, just to get a feel for what feels 'right'. You will know. Then look for basses with those specs. Lots of great options listed in this thread. 35" is not required for a good B string IME, as the B on my Wilkins is as good as it was on my 35's, but the only bad B's I've encountered were on 34's, so it varies. Don't get distracted with the pros and cons of string-through bridges, fancy tops and things like that. No one can tell the difference, IME...

Good Luck!
 
For me, string spacing is everything. I've owned nearly 60 basses, including a couple dozen 5s, and the only one I had that I couldn't get into was a Fender Jazz 5, and it was an amazing bass. Looked and sounded awesome, had a great setup, etc. But the string spacing is too wide for me to enjoy on a 5. Typically a jazz style 5 has 19mm/20mm string spacing. I prefer a 5er like a Warwick, or even a Fender MB-5, with string spacing around 16.5mm.

I'm not saying you will love or hate a specific string spacing, but I would recommend trying some before spending $1500 on a bass and then finding out you're not comfortable playing it. And before you say "I'm comfortable on a 4-string, so a 5-string with the same spacing should be fine" I would've thought the same thing, but that's not always the reality.

Sometimes we don't think it be like that, but it do.