I stopped using Gibson short scales, and went with a Hofner. The Hofner for me, is one of the finer short scales I played. 4.13 Lbs., and no neck dive.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I agree with you there, the intonation with the Hofner-style bridge is pretty hit and miss, but for what I play with my 60's band I rarely get past the 10th fret so it's a non-issue for me.
I don't think I've ever seen or heard a SS 5 string bass. Do you have a pic or can you tell us more about it?I'm 100% short scale now. Two viola basses, a jazz, and a 5 string. This website is invaluable for all the resources, but it's got a lot of opinion masquerading as fact as well.
I don't think I've ever seen or heard a SS 5 string bass. Do you have a pic or can you tell us more about it?
I love my SG basses along with my Mustang and modded Bronco basses. Always looking for something new and different sound wise. In fact right now I'm in the market for something that will fit the ultra low dub club and reggae work I'm doing. Any suggestions?I've played shorties since the mid 60s except for a few mid/late 60s, early 70s Ps and Js that I wish I had now because of what they'd be worth.
And I've heard all the reasons for not playing them from people on here.
1: They're just for children and beginners.
2: They're made from inferior parts that were left over from the real basses.
3: You can't get good strings for them.
4: They are impossible to intonate.
5: They all neck dive because of the small bodies.
6: They use cheap wood so can't have good tone.
7: The necks have to be too narrow/too wide, too thin/too chunky so they're unplayable.
8: I look silly playing one on stage as people think I'm playing a guitar.
9: All you can get is lows and no mids & highs or the all you can get is mids & highs as the strings are too short to produce lows.
10: You can't slap on one. Which I'd personally see as a very legitimate reason for using one if it were true.
Right now I have about 30 of them. Every one of them has a set of strings on it. Every one of them has the intonation set properly. Agreed on a couple (Hofner, Danelectro) it was harder to get it set properly but it can be done, it just takes time and patience and realizing it's as good as it's going to get. On both it is completely because of the bridge and not the scale. I have Guild, Fender, Gibson, Epiphone, Squier basses along with quite a few other brands and I don't consider any of my Guilds, the Gibson SS Tbird, any of the Fenders or most of my basses as beginner or child instruments. If you're a child, and your name isn't Richie Rich, you're not going to have any basses that cost in the $1,000 and up range. And a few of them are/were beginner's basses when I bought them. A couple of them still are as I like them like that but the rest have been or are in the process of being upgraded with better electronics and or hardware as that's generally where they cut corners.
Ok, inane rant over, back to watching the 4th round of the Evian Masters on TGC.
I love my SG basses along with my Mustang and modded Bronco basses. Always looking for something new and different sound wise. In fact right now I'm in the market for something that will fit the ultra low dub club and reggae work I'm doing. Any suggestions?
I don't think I've ever seen or heard a SS 5 string bass. Do you have a pic or can you tell us more about it?
Do you really believe every snowflake is different? I mean think of how many snowflakes have fallen since whenever they started falling. That number is almost bigger than the number of groupies David Lee Roth and Axl Rose had put together and you mean to tell me not TWO of them were EVER the same?

The science on that one is hazy at best, and the mathematics behind it even hazier. There's no right or wrong answer...
Invalid Link Removed
"No Two Snowflakes the Same" Likely True, Research Reveals
It's True That No Two Snowflakes Are Alike, But Not For The Reason You Think (VIDEO) | Huffington Post
I don't think I've ever seen or heard a SS 5 string bass. Do you have a pic or can you tell us more about it?