• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

SHOW YOUR DISTRESSED FINISHES!

IMG_1651.JPG
This is a NASH 63JB. I thought this one looks legit so I bought it.
 
77PBass_04.jpeg
1977 P that I bought in early 1978. For some reason during a rehearsal I did a Paul Simonon treatment and broke the body into two pieces. After regaining my composure, I repaired it and did some body work to smooth things out but never got around to repainting. It still sports the primer/filler look, but I'm used to it now. Big old neck, and it must weigh 11 pounds, but plays and sounds good. Dimarzio pickup and noname tort guard have been on there a long time too.
 
BTW on the issue of razor checking (which I'm not slagging - it's an interesting technique which takes skill and a whole lot of time), here's a 'tell', beyond general look, on why I believe that BMM is done with that method - note the places where the check lines cross over the other lines - real checking stops when it hits another crack as does forced temperature change checking:

Razor Checking.png
 
So maybe you can clear something up. I thought that mint (green) guards were called that due to that changing of color of the white guards, at least until they started intentionally making mint guards? Is that not correct? From your sample it appears the white guards should have turned more yellow than green.

Different materials. The 'green' guards (generally seen on basses mid 1962 - 1964 -- earlier on guitars) were made from celluloid/nitrate material and you're correct, they were white and discolored over time to the greenish hue.
Later '64, Fender switched to vinyl/plastic and those tend to stay more white or discolor more yellowish or towards the 'parchment' look. The one of mine in the photo is this type and is more discolored - towards yellow - than average. There were also some hybrid tort guards around this time which have plastic W-B-W with celluloid tort top layer (on those tort guards starting in 1959 all 4 layers were celluloid).
Later - like the 90's - plastic guards tinted green became common to simulate the look of the aged celluloid guards. They usually don't look all that convincing though. Partly as the old ones shrank and don't lay perfectly flat. The real ones tend to look more 'waxy' than the plastic ones as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: wraub and sneha1965
Different materials. The 'green' guards (generally seen on basses mid 1962 - 1964 -- earlier on guitars) were made from celluloid/nitrate material and you're correct, they were white and discolored over time to the greenish hue.
Later '64, Fender switched to vinyl/plastic and those tend to stay more white or discolor more yellowish or towards the 'parchment' look. The one of mine in the photo is this type and is more discolored - towards yellow - than average. There were also some hybrid tort guards around this time which have plastic W-B-W with celluloid tort top layer (on those tort guards starting in 1959 all 4 layers were celluloid).
Later - like the 90's - plastic guards tinted green became common to simulate the look of the aged celluloid guards. They usually don't look all that convincing though. Partly as the old ones shrank and don't lay perfectly flat. The real ones tend to look more 'waxy' than the plastic ones as well.

Thanks David for the thorough explanation here. You mention the guards shrink and don’t lay flat. Did you mean to say waxy or wavy?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: davidprice
View attachment 3796028 1977 P that I bought in early 1978. For some reason during a rehearsal I did a Paul Simonon treatment and broke the body into two pieces. After regaining my composure, I repaired it and did some body work to smooth things out but never got around to repainting. It still sports the primer/filler look, but I'm used to it now. Big old neck, and it must weigh 11 pounds, but plays and sounds good. Dimarzio pickup and noname tort guard have been on there a long time too.

I like the look more because it has a story behind it! :bassist:
 
  • Like
Reactions: nukebuick
BTW on the issue of razor checking (which I'm not slagging - it's an interesting technique which takes skill and a whole lot of time), here's a 'tell', beyond general look, on why I believe that BMM is done with that method - note the places where the check lines cross over the other lines - real checking stops when it hits another crack as does forced temperature change checking:

View attachment 3796038

relic forensic :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: davidprice
Different materials. The 'green' guards (generally seen on basses mid 1962 - 1964 -- earlier on guitars) were made from celluloid/nitrate material and you're correct, they were white and discolored over time to the greenish hue.
Later '64, Fender switched to vinyl/plastic and those tend to stay more white or discolor more yellowish or towards the 'parchment' look. The one of mine in the photo is this type and is more discolored - towards yellow - than average. There were also some hybrid tort guards around this time which have plastic W-B-W with celluloid tort top layer (on those tort guards starting in 1959 all 4 layers were celluloid).
Later - like the 90's - plastic guards tinted green became common to simulate the look of the aged celluloid guards. They usually don't look all that convincing though. Partly as the old ones shrank and don't lay perfectly flat. The real ones tend to look more 'waxy' than the plastic ones as well.

Yep, for fully convincing relic'ing one needs to go that extra mile focusing on the pg. On my '68 Coral, the clear pg has turned yellowish and because the body is so sculpted/tapered the flat pg, which is is relatively thick became wavy from screw to screw. Part of the gestalt of a vintage bass is how it becomes less "perfect" (new and shiny) and yet more perfect over time.

EBB4998D-58BE-424D-B119-2C7D1966620B_1_201_a.jpeg