• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Single Malt Scotch!

Where is it coming from. We sometimes don't realise the size of America. I can travel to almost every part of Scotland in a day pending ferry times to the islands.
Dave
lol, San Francisco, California, over 2000 miles away.

the USA is (very roughly) 3000 miles by 1500 miles.
 
The distilleries over here will tell you to first taste the pure whisky and if you enjoy it like that then by all means go for it. If it "burns" a little try a dash of room temperature water (a dash is a small amount of water maybe thimble size) and if it still burns try a single ice cube and let it melt a little. I've tried all of these and can drink some whisky's either way. I do quite enjoy an ice cube melted into my whisky usually if i'm busy in the kitchen as it lasts a little longer. If its a special whisky i will go for straight first and possibly add a dash of water. I find many whisky's tend to burn my throat on the way down but that might just be down to fact i don't drink very often. Maybe its a bit like chillies. The more you drink the more you get used to it. Don't drink enough to find out :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deak
The distilleries over here will tell you to first taste the pure whisky and if you enjoy it like that then by all means go for it. If it "burns" a little try a dash of room temperature water (a dash is a small amount of water maybe thimble size) and if it still burns try a single ice cube and let it melt a little. I've tried all of these and can drink some whisky's either way. I do quite enjoy an ice cube melted into my whisky usually if i'm busy in the kitchen as it lasts a little longer. If its a special whisky i will go for straight first and possibly add a dash of water. I find many whisky's tend to burn my throat on the way down but that might just be down to fact i don't drink very often. Maybe its a bit like chillies. The more you drink the more you get used to it. Don't drink enough to find out :D
Trying it straight has always been my default mode and since I started with scotch I've just left them as is since I like them so much already.
Last night was the first time I tried adding a dash of water to some Corryvreckan and it seemed to smooth things out, but I might still prefer it straight.

Just realised you said you drank straight from the bottle. Hope it was in a brown paper bag over there. :laugh:
Haven't done that in years. Did it taste any better :laugh:
Actually I reached into the display cabinet and just pulled the bottle out for a quick sip. Bunnahabhain is always good, especially the 18.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Duckophile
so i have these whisky stones which add cold but without adding water from like an ice melt. have you tried any of those?
I have some. They work adequately if the scotch is already cold, but don't cool the scotch to nearly the degree that actual ice does. I suspect that a person with a particularly sensitive palate could taste the stone's impact on the flavor profile.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vic
so i have these whisky stones which add cold but without adding water from like an ice melt. have you tried any of those?

My personal preference is for my scotch to be room temperature, as I find that there is a lot more discernable flavor when it is not chilled. I do sometimes like a splash of water, though. It varies from scotch to scotch (if I prefer the splash or if I prefer it neat). YMMV, of course!
 
so i have these whisky stones which add cold but without adding water from like an ice melt. have you tried any of those?
I was given them as a Xmas pressie few yrs back but i'm not really a fan of them. Think the actual water does a better job as its not so much cooling the whisky but diluting it that smoothes it out. When using water it should be room temperature water. That's why in whisky bars over here they have a small jug of water on the bar area rather than straight from a tap.
They are a nice conversation piece tho. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: tombowlus
Whiskey with small ice cubes or chips is good. Crunching on whiskey before you have another. Keeps you hydrated.
Over the years that i've been drinking whisky i've found that taking a dash of water or an ice cube i don't seem to get a hang-over when i'm drinking a lot altho its very rare for me to drink much more than one or two drinks these days. Not sure if there's any real truth in that but it does seem to work for me.
Dave
 
My personal preference is for my scotch to be room temperature, as I find that there is a lot more discernable flavor when it is not chilled. I do sometimes like a splash of water, though. It varies from scotch to scotch (if I prefer the splash or if I prefer it neat). YMMV, of course!
I should have added that i also can't remember the last time i used them. i totally agree, i think you can taste it best when it's room temp.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tombowlus
I was given them as a Xmas pressie few yrs back but i'm not really a fan of them. Think the actual water does a better job as its not so much cooling the whisky but diluting it that smoothes it out. When using water it should be room temperature water. That's why in whisky bars over here they have a small jug of water on the bar area rather than straight from a tap.
They are a nice conversation piece tho. :D
totally agreed.
 
Whiskey with small ice cubes or chips is good. Crunching on whiskey before you have another. Keeps you hydrated.
fwiw, i don't drink enough scotch to worry about being drunk or having a hangover. here in the states, if you want good scotch you pay dearly for it, so you sip/savor it... you don't drink a lot of it. plus i'm not much of a mixed drink person, and i hate "well" whisky... the only kind worth "wasting" in a mixed drink. bottom line is, i generally savor/sip scotch, very rarely get a buzz or a drunk from it. beer, well, that's another story. lol
 
I use to be a beer drinker (not lager tho) then i changed over to Bud good few years ago. Usually if i'm out drinking with mates i'll have a whisky and it will last same time as my mates with their pints of real ale or lager. Over here we generally get 25ml as standard for spirits which is very little in a glass. In good whisky pubs tho they will still give you the 35ml but you might pay a little more. Good whisky pubs tho are usually cheaper than your fancy modern bars so price ends up much the same. Typically over here you will pay approx £3 for a standard whisky or £4 upwards for a malt if you choose the right pubs. Think £4 equates to $5.5US Not sure if that's good or not but generally my local restaurant will have Macallan at £4.95 (approx $7US) for 35ml which isn't too bad for me
 
If i'm not driving i will always start a restaurant meal with a nice Malt and my wife a Drambuie & ice. Just gives you a nice wee appetite for eating a nice Fillet steak. Usually a nice red wine and then another malt to round off the night. mmmm that's put me right in the mood for a night out now. Shame my other hobby is forcing me to drive to a rehearsal. Ah well never mind maybe when i get home later tonight :laugh::bassist: