If “not sounding like anybody else” is the criterion for greatness, my two year-old niece banging on my bass strings should have multiple Grammy’s by now. 
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
The African Tree Climbing Perch can climb trees. However it plays the bass worse than LemmyI think you have to just recognize him for what he was. If you judge a fish on its ability to climb a tree, you are doing yourself (and the fish) no favours. He played bass the way he wanted to. He made the sound he wanted to. He didn't compare himself to anyone. He went out to support other bands. He was always true to himself.
When Motorhead first started they sounded like no other band at the time (there's some MC5 parallels to be drawn, but that was earlier). By the end of their career, they really still didn't sound like any other band.
Many bands tried to sound like Motorhead, but not the other way around.
As the Oracle at Delphi said, "Know thyself." Lemmy knew exactly who he was. I will miss him.
i get it! it makes sense to me now. thanks for responding, KBD.I posted in response & then that poster deleted their comment.
I'll admit, I should have quoted their post, in case that happened, but instead I just deleted my comment after they deleted theirs.
As far as I can tell, all the Lemmy popularity is similar to that of a William Hung or Harambe..
He may have been a great guy, but, I don't listen to music to speculate about how nice the musicians are.
Be not disturbed by that attitude. It seems common these days to denigrate someone you disagree with to make you position look wrong.I'm not amazing, but I get tired of the "Your opinion doesn't count, because you don't 'play out'" brigade.
So liking Nazi paraphernalia makes him a worthless, disgusting person?Um. Let's see....I'm not so in to it, but he DID claim to have the largest Nazi paraphernalia collection of any bassist (in the same interview he also lamented how being referred to as a bassist really irked him). So if you like Nazi stuff and play bass, but wish people referred to you as a guitar player, he was definitely your guy. :x
HahahaSo liking Nazi paraphernalia makes him a worthless, disgusting person?
What's wrong with you?
There seems to be a lot of love for him on this site and I'd like to join the party.
I like his voice, he's got the appropriate rock and roll attitude, but his basslines are rudimentary and his tone is trebley and to my ears, unpleasant.
For context, I like my music funkier and more harmonically developed (Steely Dan, Earth Wind and Fire, Tower of Power, as well as fusion artists such as Tribal Tech, etc.), however I enjoy and respect many rock bassist, i.e. Jack Bruce, John Paul Jones, Geddy Lee, McCartney, Sting.
Amen....I stopped reading after the first page. Sorry everyone.
Don't think of Lemmy as a 'bass player.' He's not laying down basslines in the traditional sense of that dynamic.
He's acting like a rhythm guitarist and frontman, but doing it on bass. If you step out of the 'this is what a bass' place traditionally is in a band' you'll have a much better chance of digging what he's doing. Also it helps to not be all serious about bassskillz in the classic sense. Lemmy is a player who carved out his own place in the music and in music in a greater sense.
Or to turn it around a bit, look at a guy like Peter Hook (New Order/Revenge/Joy Division)...he took bass and rather than going low, went high and lead melodic...another player who shattered the paradigm.
I like bass players who see the box that we put the instrument in...and promptly knock out the walls.
I'm a huge fan of Heavy Metal but I never really got into Motorhead.
whenever I tell anyone I'm not really a fan they look at me like I'm from another planet
Lemmy never wanted MH to be labeled Heavy Metal.
Most of those people only know Ace of Spades.
Sort of like the folks wearing Ramones shirts that only know "I Wanna Be Sedated".