---When using Output 1 with my BSY600, it didn't seem to have quite the same range as my Yamaha FC-7. I thought these were both 50 kOhm pots. More oddly, the lack of range is in the heel position, not the toe position. It's not that significant in terms of what I was to do with the BSY600, but it was noticeable in extensive A/B-ing of the two.
---When using Output 2 with my Eventide Modfactor, there were some problems. This was a little more expected because the Eventide expects 25 kOhm TS and the DEP puts out 50 kOhm TRS. I thought with the knob I could dial it back, but it doesn't work how I would expect. I can get the dial on the DEP pretty close so that the action is from 0 to 100 (the Eventide shows this digitally), though it's not perfect. In addition to not being perfect (but probably close enough for most of what I'll do), the bigger issue is that my Eventide interprets it backwards. 0 is toe down, 100 is heel down. For parameter adjustments, this is okay I think; I'm pretty sure I can just program the Eventide "backwards"---i.e., it doesn't matter what values I program in for toe and heel position. But it's a little weird for real-time modulation control. (NOTE: Through all of this, I was using a TS cable. A TRS cable was unresponsive.)
(*snip*)
QUESTIONS:
---What is the allen wrench in the box for? The manual says nothing about it and I don't see any places that use it.
---The manual says Output 1 and the Sensor output cannot be used simultaneously, but I tried it and it seems to work. I'm not sure what is going on here?
Hi! This is Brett from Source Audio. I actually signed up for the TalkBass forums just to post a reply. Hopefully I can answer your questions here.
NOTE: I took several photos and tried to upload them to this thread, but I'm not able to include them in my post. It seems that new TalkBass forum members have to be registered for a few days and create a few posts before photos are allowed... For now, I hope a plain text explanation will suffice!
EDIT: I was able to add pictures!
SA161 Potentiometer Range
The SA161 (Dual Expression Pedal) is indeed a 50 kOhm potentiometer. There are two factors that contribute to the limited range. First, on the high end (toe down), the potentiometer might not reach its full 50 kOhms. This is because potentiometers generally have a fairly wide manufacturing tolerance. Unfortunately, there's not much we can do about this. On the low end of things, however (heel down), you should be able to get very close to 0 Ohms. There's one catch: in order to prevent the pedal from making a loud clicking sound, we include a small rubber disk in the mechanical design. This gives a small bit of resistance when the heel is down, preventing loud clicks. The tradeoff is that it prevents the potentiometer from achieving its full range.
Link Removed
I took a pedal from our warehouse and did a quick check with an ohmmeter. In the heel down position, it got down to about 1.3 kOhm, or 2% of the full range. With additional pressure, I could get it down to 100 Ohms or less, but that's obviously not ideal.
So, I took a knife and cut away some of the rubber. I used a utility knife, but the rubber is soft enough that even a steak knife would do it.
Without the rubber, the modified pedal now has little to no rubber preventing the moving parts from coming into contact.
Link Removed
Link Removed
At this point, I took out the ohmmeter again to measure the resistance of the potentiometer in the heel position. This time, I was able to get down to about 20 or 30 Ohms. That's only 0.05% of the full range, which is effectively zero in any real application.
The tradeoff, of course, is that now the pedal makes a clicking sound when I go to the full heel position - that's why we included the rubber in the design. It's a bit of a tradeoff - you can only really get the full range if the two pieces of metal are flush. If you want to get the full range of the potentiometer, but don't like the click, you could maybe try to cut a little less rubber than I did, or put a little piece of electrical tape over the bottom of the rubber to create a very thin barrier between the treadle and the rest of the pedal chassis. That would be a good way to find a happy medium.
[EDIT: I broke my four answers into four separate posts in order to avoid having a very long single post! Hope that makes sense...]
I hope that info is helpful. Let me know if you have additional questions!
Brett