I'm certainly in a similar camp. I've been shifting a little bit on 2 ends. First bit has been more towards stuff on the board being more about functional capability and space efficiency. It doesn't have to sound perfect, long as it's close enough, I'll never notice in a mix. If it sounds good, it is good. Doesn't need to be perfect or the best.
ie I've yet to bounce my heavy weapon off the board even though some of the muffs I have I like better in some ways. Why I keep it though? It can get me lower to medium grit w/ amazing clarity, up to real good wooly fuzz tones with a great octave (that standds out when you want) and tone that sits great in a mix. But when you combine em, it just sounds over the top good as well. Of course a bit different than a muff, and on its own covers all the ground I'd need in a gig. Because of that, I don't need half a dozen muffs. Couple would be good enough to cover anything I'd need for recording or messing around.
I'm toying with keeping my tri pie muff and getting a sovtek deluxe to cover the Civil War and Russian ones but purging the rest. I'm hard on the fence with the big box eye see '78. It does sound a lot better and different IMO than the small box one, I have a feeling the CMC version with the mids knob might be able to get close enough.
I've done a ton of messing around with all the muff variations I have and noticed a few things in the mix. Triangles tend to have a different hi-mid or whatever frequency focal point for the tone. It's seems more on the vocal end vs just brightness/presence of other muffs. Even though it seems fairly scooped, it sits/stands out real well in the mix, possibly the best if you're looking to have clear articulation. Reminds me of the difference between running both on a PJ vs just the P pickup. Both sit well in the mix, even though one is comb filtered/scooped, and clarity is solid but with both there is more bright articulation.
Civil war tends to stand real well in the mix despite being darker and realistically is like the P only in the analogy above.
Also for anyone else that hasn't messed with it before, something cool seems to happen on most muffs at about 9 o'clock on the tone knob. Almost like a low mid resonance bump, reminiscent of rolling your tone knob on a bass all the way off. Really cool on the IC muff I have and whatever variant the Warlow is.
Anyway, I've talked too much
The other thing I've been shifting on is if it's not on the board(s) and can be replaced readily without paying an arm and a leg or at a hefty loss, i need to just move it on unless I know I will use/ mess around with it regularly.
Hell, I'm even debating on getting rid of my "first" pedal. Not sure how I feel on that one though and I honestly may never use it again. Works perfect though.
Lastly, I couldn't pass up on this deal, even though I'd rather pick up a Sander's Jag or Wattplower. Plays great, the J pickup actually balances perfect with the P. Without any volume loss too. My first real active bass, and the first one I've actually liked the preamp on to a significant extent. Not that others are bad, but this one seems to do what I'd want, but at the same time sound great with everything set flat. And yes, I did take off the cover. I didn't mind it, and if it was over the P I'd have left it. It is exactly where you'd be plucking/picking if you palm mute.
Tldr; I've resigned myself to just jump on deals like this and mystery boxes for the next few years. Besides picking up a zoia and a simple looper...
View attachment 7186988