AX-Synth... i kid... unless...
not speaking for JMJ, this is simply a new-found interest of mine. i was in a similar situation, and used the JMJ post as well as your midi foot pedals post during my search.
i also came across this site- it's a good resource for me. the "synth finder" tab is cool:
http://www.vintagesynth.com/
though some synths are better than others, it basically comes down to a good synth can reproduce most other synth sounds (pending the number of oscillators, available wave forms, etc.)
as i am on a budget, and really want a "starter" synth, i went with a alesis micron. it sounds good but it is difficult to change the parameters (usually use my computer to edit patches). i am looking into midi foot controllers now (leaning toward the budget fatar stuff). JMJ has said that he digs the micron's big bro, the ion (which i believe was discontinued).
some basic things you need to decide on-
new or vintage?
digital, analogue, or soft synth?
mono, poly, both options?
price range?
i was looking for a newer synth (to patch direct to a computer or 1/4" out); wanted mono, but didn't rule out poly; 3-4 octave; less money... options i considered:
-korg ms2000 (discontinued, lots of knobs that make learning the nuts'n'bolts of synthesizing easy)
-korg microkorg (good sounds, hard to edit, didn't like the little keys)
-korg mono/poly (vintage synth... didn't want to spend $ on upkeep)
-novation xio, x station, k station, and bass station (25 key, 49 key, or 61 key versions)
-roland has a few models (sh, juno)
if i had the $ to spend, i would have went w/ a moog little phatty (it is mono) or a nord stage.
if you do a jmj thread search, i recall he mentions
digital-korg microkorg, alesis ion, novation bass station
digital &/or analog- dave smith stuff, and moog little phatty
analog- moog rogue/realistic mg-1, octave kat
JMJ's gear post mentions a few synths that he owns.
the bassplayer article says he uses a softsynth setup w/ NIN- Novation ReMote 25SL, Apple Xserve-based softsynth rig