Ok, just putting on my professional UX design hat:
The idea of a small, portable brick with lots of DSP is appealing, and in fact practical with modern SoCs.
The interface isn’t really practical at that size. Certainly not for live use.
And while ICE power amps are small they’re not
that small, and still require cooling.
So even if we had an all-DSP amp with a Class D power section, if it’s intended for live use, it needs to be rugged, easy to set up and use on a dark stage. It’s going to have a certain minimum size to accommodate heat sinks and cooling fans.
From a usability perspective, it needs to match some basic rules (adapted from
Jakob Nielsen’s heuristics)
- Visibility of system status. It should be clear what’s going on with the system at all times.
- Match between the system and the real world. Use common language to describe and label things, don’t assume users know things or use technical jargon. Controls and inputs map intuitively, vs requiring menu diving or “modes”.
- User control and freedom. This means both designing the system to avoid errors, and providing ways for users to undo a mistake.
- Consistency and standards. It shouldn’t feel totally alien, rather, it should map to users’ experiences with similar products. Symbols and terminology should be standardized - the user shouldn’t have to guess what something means or what the result of an action will be.
- Aesthetic and minimal design - which doesn’t mean minimalism per se, but the user interface and physical design should not be confusing or include irrelevant information.
Too often, music gear and software is not designed with usability in mind; trying to cram a desktop interface into a pedalboard is a recipe for frustration.
Even analog gear can suffer from this - there’s lots of full-featured preamp pedals that sound great, for instance, but have confusing layouts, labelling, signal paths, tiny side switches, etc.
Things like the choice of knobs affects this - how often do you see ones without line pointers or whose indicators aren’t easily visible (especially on pedals?)
There are things like rotary encoders with built-in displays that could be used, to preserve that analog knob feel while giving users a clear setting indication visible at a distance. This one is the open-source RoenDi:
View attachment 5440606