A bit of a repost but I've also been completely won over by the 35" 4 string thing. Here's my story.
Two years ago I came across a used Carlo in Carl Pedigo's basement-of-Lakland workhop. I was initially drawn by the 1.75" nut (rare on boutique instruments) but the "35 scale was amazing. Put it on layaway and brought it home a few months later.
NBD: My Carlo. Lakland lines but with a little something extra.
It's basically a custom 4-94
It immediately became my most played bass and I so loved the 35" scale that I decided to get a similarly scaled and dimensioned fretless. My Wendler arrived last year and it's also amazing. Completely worth the 5 instruments (including my last 5 string) I sold to pay for it.
NBD: Wendler Electrocoustic (Chttps://www.talkbass.com/threads/its-like-a-nbd-low-down-bass-overhauls-my-jazz.1321267/ustom Cedar-Bodied 35" Fretless)
Then last year I asked Tim Seisser of "Lowdown Bass" make a conversion neck for my parts jazz based on the neck on my Carlo.
It's like a NBD! Low Down Bass overhauls my Jazz!
Loving it.
The Lowdown mod turned out so well, I'm having Tim build a new 35", 70's style Telebass to house the two darkstars that formerly resided in a Decade-style parts bass I had built. After I get this bass I will probably turn the Carlo into BEAD to better serve the gospel music I've been playing on Sunday mornings.
The end result is that by the end of the year I will have downsized from 11 or so electric basses to 6. All will have p-width necks and asside from my T-40 and my first bass (a much modded MIM P) they will all be 35", 4 strings.
Here's the three 35" 4 strings I have so far.
View attachment 3123960
I really could be happy with just these, but I so loved the sound of the darkstar pickups in my old (much too heavy) franken bass that I think having a bass built for them that will be even lighter (a priority for me these days) than the Jazz will really wrap things up nicely.