So the artist had a handful of ideas, I narrowed it down to two I liked, milled out a couple enclosures and printed both, and I powdercoated them last night so I could see what they're really going to look like.
So I'm like 95% done with the decision. There was one that I liked a little more than the other, but when I printed them it didn't pop as much as the other one, so the one I liked less on the screen I now like better on the enclosure. They both look really good, but one just translated to a metal background better, and I'll probably go with that one. I've set a deadline of tonight for myself to make a decision, and I already have a circuit board ready to go so putting the full pedal together should take all of 5 minutes, and I should be able to have a final reveal tonight.
tl;dr - FINAL REVEAL, 9PM CENTRAL TIME TONIGHT.