Obviously I'm a little biased, but any of my preamps will kick the snot out of a valvecaster any day of the week and twice on Sunday. Valvecaster runs starved voltages on the plates which technically works, but in my only-occasionally-humble opinion Valvecaster's main appeal is as a low-gain overdrive, running it clean without breakup it's not that special. A high-voltage tube preamp would fit the bill much better.
P.S. Interestingly enough Valvecaster was actually the very first pedal I ever built, the one that started me into this hobby. I did it as a project for my Intro to Circuits class in college 7 years ago
I think London Underground or Particle Accelerator would both be good bets for all clean no breakup. If you're willing to tolerate a little breakup I think Dr. Wattson is going to be hard to beat, that's becoming my new favorite preamp for bass. Sunnday Drive is awesome and has good cleans, but it can also get SUPER heavy, especially with the boost.
I think one of the next pedals I want to tackle would be a simple two-knob, single tube preamp just for warmth without tone shaping. The more I hear about what people want the more I think that idea is a winner. Plus I could probably do it small and (relatively) cheap.